Gurfateh
Respected Manbir Singh Ji,
das has read many of the writings of Sirdir Sahib and supports him for his real concern for the panth and without any hitch his delclaring of Tankhiya is unjust.
Most of his writings are in Punjabi(das is not expert but has workable knwoledge of it).
Yet Sirdir Sahib work based upon Dasham Granth is more near to work of Sirdir Sahib Bhag Singh Ji Ambala another great Sikh who underwent similer agony.
Das can say that Sirdir Sahib are not understanding the meaning of Guru Granth Sahib Ji in correct sense and therefore find it contradictory to Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
As it was in history like it was in meat issue we had a good lot of diffrances.
Das is from Nirmala order but not only in Nirmalas but in Taksalis also in past there was a great lot of diferances on weather the whole Dasham Granth is from Guru or not.
So if some missioariers are oppsoing it then it does not mean that it is some thing new.Even in past also there were idfferances on Raagmala also.
Coing back to objectionable part of Dasham Granth like Triya charitra.Das can say that vaste nationas are not made merely by spritual discourse.
We need Techniques like that of Armuray(Shastra Maal Puraan) .
non of the Missioaries like Ambala Sahib or Kala Afghana Sahib are from intelligense agency or politics or Army(in guirilla warfare) or diplomacy.
Reason for thier getting unfair deals by idiotic fake Akalis highjacking sgpc etc. ie main reason for that.
Yet had they have taken some tips from Triya Charitar then today they would have succesfully overthrown the cruppot people who are haivng control on sorry to say up to some extent Akal Takhat.
Das had already started one thread on Triaya Charitar and wil explain what it means.
Das is not going by any tranlation but what is writtan thier in Braj Bhasha and explantion of it in English will be given.Das will try to touch Hiqyats also which are in Farsi and try to give what message is it giving.
Das is reapeating that since old time there were many ways to transfer coded messages and at present too we are tought.
visit the thread Das started.
http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/sikhphilosophy/controversial-debates/5784-kanjer-kavita-title-triya-charitars.html
Das is trying to use the brain of missioariers so let them understand.
das has personal opinion that Dasham Granth is more to do with semitic faiths or say like Islam.And Panth could be termed as youngest of semitic faith ie Jews,Chrsitians,Islam and Latest the Panth.
In fact in India in order to attract Hindus Catholics have taken a few steps.
1. performing Arti of trinity in churches with lamp etc.
2. Learning Sanskrit and Vedas
3.Accpeting offering like Coconuts.
Similar acts in past ere done by sufies to preach Islam like Malik Moahmud Jayeesi who used Hindu Mythology to preach Islam.
Sunni preachers in India also quote Vedas to preach Islam.
So Dasham Granth was an attempt by Sikhs to preach Gurmat to Hindus and other non Sikhs.
