• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Reply to thread

They don't need Dasam Granth because they already have the original Hindu texts, instead of translations. A Sikh only needs Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Not translations from Markandya Puran or Bhavat Puran or whatever other texts were used to create Dasam Granth. I don't understand your love for arya smajis and videnta. It doesn't matter what they believe or what they don't believe. Focus of Sikh is what Guru Granth Sahib Ji says. Guru Granth Sahib Ji says Ika Bani Ik Gur Ikko Shabad Veechar. No Dasam Granth or Sarabloh Granth. Guru Gobind Singh Ji was equal to other Gurus so if he had written by Gurbani, it would have been in Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Fifth Nanak added own bani in Aad Granth Ji so there was no restriction on 10th Nanak either. Dhirmalleas and prithias type created another granth to fool Sikhs.

 

Those definitions of Charturbhuj are correct. Kahan Singh says God is the caretaker in all directions. How does God take our care? God gives to us. It doesn't mean God has four arms at all and Bhai Kahan Singh says the same thing. Why would you try to fool Sikhs then? Other than that, Dasam Granth's chaturbhuj is about 4 physical arms because he is none other than Mahakaal. He has conch in one hand, snakes in neck, etc. so it is clearly not God of Gurbani. Sarpanee is maayaa so God is maayaadhaari?

 

As said before Vijaydeep, please don't try to fool Sikhs. Especially not on sites where people are awake.


Top