Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!

Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
Sign up Log in

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Randip Singh" data-source="post: 164485" data-attributes="member: 1323">No he doesn't!!The shabads are about tyranny and false religious people.Either you don't understand what I am saying or you are dodging it. I repeat again. As soon as you pull out a one liner you distort the shabad. This appears to be what you are doing.I'm not jumping ahead of the discssion but pointing out that you cannot isolate one line from a shabad because you distort it. Post the entire shabad and discuss it.I'm not at all. I'm using English side by side translitration. Translitration = Gurmukhi writtem in English, not a translation. This is for the benefit of those people who come on this forum and don't read Gurmukhi. No I don't agree.Kabir may have been a vegetarian just like Sheikh Farid a meat eater, but both are irrelevant to this discussion.All that matters is what teh shabads meean and what the 6 Nanaks thought when they included them in Bani. By pulling out one liners you're distorting their meanings.If you won't discuss the entire shabad there is no point to this discussion to be honest (something you appear to be reluctant to do so).:whatzpointsing:</blockquote>