New posts

Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!

Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
Sign up Log in

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="ekmusafir_ajnabi" data-source="post: 50474" data-attributes="member: 4318">Randip ji a dead body is a body without life whether it is lying in the street or a slaughter house. It can belong to human or for that matter to an animal. You may not see meat in it but for a hungry animal it is a source of food - it is flesh - it is meat.I am now getting the impression that you are denying the existance of the word meat. Are you ?If it makes you happy to refer to me as a "Pandit" then that is fine. A Pandit is a person with knowledge. I will put my argument forward with a backing and you do the same.I have given you a constructive response and had requested you to respond in a similar way. The information presented is very legible. I have broken it down as much as possible so evry one can understand it. As an authority on this subject please back your statements like a professional would do. Allow me access to your research data on this topic so that I can satisfy for myself that all the t's have been crossed and i's dotted. I am not pushing any views forward. I have presented your with my understanding of the translations. I have backed up the translations with references to data from our Sikh Encyclopedias without which your translation would have not have existed. What do you have to hide. Allow me access to your research. Please also do not jump to conclusions. Be mature with your response. Tackle me with factual information which you should have.It is sad to see such comments coming from a learned person like you. I will not stoop down to your level again. I did that in the past.If you do consider your self to be a historian/researcher on sikh philosophy then please behave accordingly and with honour. Present your aguments in a civilised manner."Changa nao rakhie ke jas kirat jag le, Je TIS nazar na aavaee ta vaat na pushe ke" I have gone beyond that many lifes ago. I have the blessing of my gurus with me.Just give me a straight forward answer. Yes or No. Can you backup your research?What is the source of your information?Whose translations are you using and why?Are the translations your interpretation?If you are or consider yourself a follower of Guru Granth Sahib.Your reply would be "YES" and you will provide me your research information.If you are an iimposter only set to gain fame by disgracing the memory of our Gurus. Then your answer will be "No".Answers in between will mean "Malice" then May god have mercy on you.Dhan Guru Amar Das ji.</blockquote>

Verification