• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

General Ghosts

Do you beleive in ghosts

  • I beleive in ghosts

    Votes: 8 36.4%
  • I don't beleive in ghosts

    Votes: 7 31.8%
  • I don't know I don't care about them

    Votes: 7 31.8%

  • Total voters
    22

kds1980

SPNer
Apr 3, 2005
4,502
2,743
44
INDIA
Recently there was a good discussion on another sikh site about ghosts.
so i am starting a poll here. Whether the present spn sangat beleive in ghosts.

Also if you have any ghost stories to share then please share
 

Sherab

SPNer
Mar 26, 2007
441
20
USA
Yes - Gurbani supports the view that there are ghosts.

ਜਿਤੁ ਦਿਨਿ ਦੇਹ ਬਿਨਸਸੀ ਤਿਤੁ ਵੇਲੈ ਕਹਸਨਿ ਪ੍ਰੇਤੁ ॥
On that day when the body perishes-at that time, she becomes a ghost.

ਪਸੁ ਪ੍ਰੇਤ ਮੁਘਦ ਪਾਥਰ ਕਉ ਤਾਰੈ ॥
Even beasts, ghosts and the stone-hearted are saved.

ਕਈ ਕੋਟਿ ਭੂਤ ਪ੍ਰੇਤ ਸੂਕਰ ਮ੍ਰਿਗਾਚ ॥
Many millions are the evil-nature spirits, ghosts, pigs and tigers.

Sources (by line):

Ang 134 of SGGS, Ang 274, Ang 276, all by Guru Arjan Dev ji.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Sara

SPNer
Dec 24, 2004
5
0
37
Finland
No, it's difficult to believe that when a person dies, her soul or spirit just stays here hanging around and scaring people.

Gurbani can't be interpreted literally, at the same time neglecting the true meaning of the lines. I feel that the word "ghost" is just used as a metaphor and to add lyrical power to what is being said.
 

Sherab

SPNer
Mar 26, 2007
441
20
USA
No, it's difficult to believe that when a person dies, her soul or spirit just stays here hanging around and scaring people.

Gurbani can't be interpreted literally, at the same time neglecting the true meaning of the lines. I feel that the word "ghost" is just used as a metaphor and to add lyrical power to what is being said.
If the mind is deeply attached to something, it may linger here as a ghost - not that people die and stay here forever, but rather, they die and remain attached - which you then see as a form of the persons mind, as a ghost, until they are reborn.
 
Apr 4, 2007
934
29
i think the concept of "ghost" in western culture is a little bit different than "paret" in gurbani.

in the west, we consider a ghost to be the lost soul of someone who has died. gurbani sees paret/ghost as one of the 84 lakh joon.

ਅੰਤਿ ਕਾਲਿ ਜੋ ਮੰਦਰ ਸਿਮਰੈ ਐਸੀ ਚਿੰਤਾ ਮਹਿ ਜੇ ਮਰੈ
Anṯ kāl jo manḏar simrai aisī cẖinṯā meh jė marai.
At the very last moment, one who thinks of mansions, and dies in such thoughts,

ਪ੍ਰੇਤ ਜੋਨਿ ਵਲਿ ਵਲਿ ਅਉਤਰੈ ॥੪॥
Parėṯ jon val val a­uṯarai. ||4||
shall be reincarnated over and over again as a goblin. ||4||
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Apr 4, 2007
934
29
If the mind is deeply attached to something, it may linger here as a ghost - not that people die and stay here forever, but rather, they die and remain attached - which you then see as a form of the persons mind, as a ghost, until they are reborn.


actually, as i understand the concept, they're reborn as a ghost, not waiting to be reborn.

maybe i'm missing something?
 

kds1980

SPNer
Apr 3, 2005
4,502
2,743
44
INDIA
No, it's difficult to believe that when a person dies, her soul or spirit just stays here hanging around and scaring people.

Gurbani can't be interpreted literally, at the same time neglecting the true meaning of the lines. I feel that the word "ghost" is just used as a metaphor and to add lyrical power to what is being said.

Its possible that souls of some people stay hanging around
 

Sherab

SPNer
Mar 26, 2007
441
20
USA
actually, as i understand the concept, they're reborn as a ghost, not waiting to be reborn.

maybe i'm missing something?
That is actually, correct.

The correct term in Pali would be Peta, in Sanskrit, it is Preta - I do not know the panjabi for such a term.
 
Oct 14, 2007
3,369
54
Sachkhand
Closest Punjabi term would be an expression ' bhoot- pret' or sometime if there is a context of discussion even 'pret' also works well.
I don't have a story except I know that I am not a Tibetian Monk or anyone practicising Yoga sans Asanas.
 

Sherab

SPNer
Mar 26, 2007
441
20
USA
Closest Punjabi term would be an expression ' bhoot- pret' or sometime if there is a context of discussion even 'pret' also works well.
I don't have a story except I know that I am not a Tibetian Monk or anyone practicising Yoga sans Asanas.
there is yoga with asanas in Tibetan Buddhism, just nopt the stretching your thinking of. the tibetan term for physical yoga is 'phrul skor (wylie trnascription) - pronounced Trul kor. Trul kor is bacially from the chakrasamvara tantra, and mainly practiced as the six yogas of naropa, however, that is mainly in kagyu. Nyingma too has trul korm but its not necessairly the six physical yogas.

In kagyu-pa, it is anuttarayoga tantra, and physical excersizes in Nyingma are mainly found on mahayoga sadhanas, ie. the 9 herukas. :D
 

spnadmin

1947-2014 (Archived)
SPNer
Jun 17, 2004
14,500
19,219
Sherab ji

This is actually an interesting topic. I think of the individual's soul as something that is very fluid and has the capacity to merge with energies beyond the limits of its own being. In its travel toward and within something Greater does it make contact with other energies (maybe not the best word)? Or is it always in contact with other energies? Could what we are calling "ghosts" be projections from within ourselves that are recordings of those interactions of the soul. Our mind gives the energy form? Just my thinking. These bhoots and prets take form only as the mind projects the soul's energy. Once we put the mind's creations in proper perspective, the bhoots and preets recede back to their origin. Again, just me wondering.
 

spnadmin

1947-2014 (Archived)
SPNer
Jun 17, 2004
14,500
19,219
In connecting with other "energies" the soul might connect with enlightened souls or strong positive protective souls. So-called "ghosts" do not have to be "bhoots" or "prets"

Here is something shared with me by another forum member; he sent it by private message. There is a "bibi" in the story who in deep vairaag may have made the connection and then the projection I described in the previous post with energies of the shaheeds.

I am not posting this as "ghost stories" but just as a possibility that souls contact souls. We are always connected, and the mind tries to make sense of things.

Shaheed Singhs and their duty to protect GurSikhs

shaheeds.jpg



Their faces glow of redness, and their eyes shine. They have strong builds. They wear full bana, and are always shasterdhari. There are Singhs and Singhnia, both wear cholas (blue) and adorn dhumallas. They have khandas on these dumallas. They come with specific purposes upon the Hukam of Akaal.

-Bhai Rama Singh Ji

Below are some of the narrated episodes of those who have witnessed Shaheed Singhs come to protect that which is dear to the Guru. They have been entrusted to Panthic Seva even when they are already in the next world. It is believed that these Shaheed Singhs come to the protection of GurSikhs. Gurudwaras and also to continue to pay respect wherever the Word of the Guru’s Bani is recited in complete devotion.Though they are at rest with the Akaal Purakh, they are still sent forth by the Guru to continue the work of the Guru and sent forth into the physical world in accordance with the Guru’s instructions. The following accounts are published to build faith in the Gurus so that we may not waver in our trust in Him.


Shaheed Singhs are basically Pure Spirits, all of us are born with them, and they are with us at all times whenever we most need help. When we are born we start clinging to Maya and get polluted with it, to forget why we came here, we loose our great Essence of Purity we once had when we came onto this Earth. Shaheed Singhs help and guide you on the path of Sikhi, but if one does not make that effort to lead the life of a Gursikh, Shaheed Singhs will never come to their help. We only need to realise this and make a start on the path for them to help us.


Guarding Gurudwaras
There is an army of Shaheed Singhs that have been ordered by Guru Sahib to constantly protect Gurdwaras and Gursikhs. They are the special forces of Guru Sahib and completely one with him. They are very powerful and even greater than the Hindu gods who do not have as much power. The Shaheed Singhs dress in old Khalsa bana, either blue or sometimes white, and also carry many shastars. Although they usually go about in secret and cannot be seen, at times they make themselves visible. These Shaheed Singhs have been seen during the 1947 Partition, guarding Gurdwaras and at other times have helped Singhs protect Guru Granth Sahib Ji.



Shaheed Singhs & Singhnia in the SaadhSangat
There was an incident at the second Bangor based Khalsa Camp. I was given seva in the Darbar sahib. I was standing at the back on the Darbar Sahib during a late night keertan darbar. Bhai Rama Singh Ji was sitting down quite close to me. The keertan was very Chardikala, and the sangat was mast in Waheguru Simran. The lights had been switched, but for a lamp near Guru Maharaj. Everyone was deeply engrossed in Bani. There was bibi who attended the camp. It had quite a bit of impact on her, and she was getting Biaraig in the keertan. At the side of the darbar there was a double door out to a graden area. They were closed, but suddenly the doors flung open. I think the weather was not too good, so I walked over and closed them again. At this point, the keertan was every higher in Chardikala. The bibi had become so mast in Bani, that she was physically affected. The bibi then turned and did matah tek, and stayed in that position, and sat again in Guru ji presence, and was even more mast. The whole sangat was highly engrossed in Naam and Bani. The keertan went on till quite late and was very memorable. The next day, after Amritvela, myself and Bhai Rama Singh ji were sitting in the langar hall having langar. Possible there were other Gursikhs there as well. Bhai Sahib and I were talking about the keertan the night before. We were both agreeing it was really excellent, and we were blessed to experience these darbars. I asked Bhai sahib about the bibi. I said why did she matte tek in the other direction? Bhai sahib replied, ‘Did you not see them?’ I replied, ‘See who?’ Bhai sahib said, ‘The shaheed Singhs who entered the Darbar. They came to join the SadhSangat. She bowed to them.’ I became highly intrigued by this. I said, ‘Bhai sahib, tell me about them?’ He replied, ‘Its no matter really, if you did not see, then forget about it.’ I was not going to let this drop, so began harrasing him for a few minutes. Eventually Bhai Sahib came around, and starting talking. He said ‘They are special souls who came to listen to Bani in the SadhSangat.’ Upon detailed questioning Bhai sahib revealed a basic description, extremely reluctantly. He said, ‘Their faces glow of redness, and their eyes shine. They have strong builds. They wear full bana, (as in a blue chola), and are always shasterdhari. There are Singhs and Singhnia, both wear cholas (blue) and adorn dhumallas. They have khandas on these dumallas. They come with specific purposes upon the Hukam of Akaal.’ I kept pressing Bhai sahib for more, but he was very relunctant and telling me to just Naam aap. But I was young, and really interested, and Bhai Sahib knew he could not distract me. I asked tell me more about them. But he kept saying, forget it. ‘Eventually to stop me, he said, do you know ___________ Singh in UK? They all look like that. Now let’s go to the lecture.’ I have not mentioned the Gursikhs name because he is still alive and does seva in the jatha in UK. I think most people will guess who it is anyway. When you go to rainsbhais, there is always one elder that stands out. A few weeks later, Bhai sahib and I were at a Gursikhs house in Southall. A youth had drawn a sketch picture, it was of a scene of 1984, showing the damaged Siri Akal Thakht Sahib. From the sky through the clouds he had drawn Shaheed Singhs coming to the Akal Thakht. The scene was amazing. Both myself and Bhai Sahib looked at it for some time. I am not sure what the inspiration was for that Youth, but the picture he had drawn was amazing.



Shaheeds answer Fateh
Bhai Soorat Singh was a Gursikh who even in 1949 used to do yatra of Hemkunt Sahib. He says that, “Every year I would go from Gobind Dham to Hemkunt Sahib and in the evening return back. I would do the bhog of a sehaj paath there in 15 or 16 days. When I would o paath there though, I wouldn’t speak but sometimes it seemed to me tha thte Gurdwara Sahib was filled with Singhs and sometimes there was no one. On the day of the bhog, I finished by saying a Fateh! And to my surprise, it was answered by 16 Singhs sitting in the sangat. Five or six of them were wearing blue clothes and the rest were wearing white. All had shastars. One Singh stood and said, “Bhai Sahib, do not doubt us. We are 16 Shaheed Singhs in this Gurdwara and many others also go around here.”



Incident at the Sarovar
Many times I would spend the night in the veranda and I would hear the keertan of Asa Dee Vaar. Once, at 3:15, I was sitting in the veranda when I saw a being riding on a white lion come, bathe in the sarovar and then ride off again on the lion.



Singh protecting the tent of a Sant
The Shaheed Singhs also stay with Gursikhs at all times. During the time of Sant Attar Singh jee, it was seen that a Singh riding a horse would circumambulate Sant jee’s tent. The tent was on the banks of the Jehlum, and the horse would go on the three sides which were faced by land, but also on the fourth side which was the river Jehlum. The rider would yell out a jaikara as well. When Sant jee was asked about this, he said that Shaheed Singhs do come and protect Gursikhs but those that can see this should not tell others.



Guarding Singhs
Naam Abhyaasi Gursikh Subedaar Baghael Singh once told me that in Shaheedi Fauj of Guru Gobind Singh Ji is properly organised and there are several Generals in it. Bhai Bachitter Singh is one of the top most Generals in Shaheedi Fauj.

Subedaar Baghael Singh told me that he personally once got darshan of Bhai Bachitter Singh Ji. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji once casually mentioned to a Singh that there are always 4 Singhs present in the Narangwal area (Bhai Sahib’s pind) to guard the Singhs there.


Baba Harnaam Singh of Rampurkhera is said to have had several encounters with Shaheed Singhs.


Shaheed Singh in the Gurudwara
At a gurdwara sahib I went to regularly, the double doors to the gurdwara main hall which faced outside would swing open by themselves sometimes. There would be no wind at all and all of a sudden, they would open. This was not during a time when there was much sangat, but just me standing there. This happened on a few occassions but did not happen after that time.



Once when coming to the gurdwara sahib late at night, I was on the road in the car and looked at the gurdwara’s window. The light of the main hall was on and I noticed the outline of a Singh with round dastar and open beard walking by the window. When we came in, there was no one, and we found that everyone was asleep and no one was up at that time when I asked the next day. I’m sure I saw a Singh though.


Ever-present
As a young child of about 3 holding my late dad’s finger and walking along one evening reciting Rehrass . . . I distinctly remember hearing hoof beats following us at the back . . . when I turned to have a look, my dad reprimanded me and said, “Dont look back. It is a Shaheed Singh Ji and he is following us because we are reciting Gurbani.



At age 12 due to some financial difficulties my dad and mum had to work out station and we children were left on our own. I being the ledest was in charge. We would go upstairs to our second storey balcony and gaze far to see dad coming back every evening. One night we waited until almost midnight and dad still hadnt tunred up…suddenly we heard a neighing sound and a Shastar Dharee Singh Ji on a White Horse so tall that it reached up to the second story balcony appeared in front of us in a shining white light and we heard a voice that dad was in the local hospital in a coma due to an accident. I quickly got downstairs and cycled five miles to the local hospital and sure enough there was my dad with two broken arms after being involved in a motor accident…the surgeon wanted to shave his arms for an operation to reset the badly smashed bone and he awoke just in time to say no way . . . he healed very well without any surgery.


Later my dad related to me that this particular shaheed singh was a Bhai Darshan Singh who had been martyred in a Battle with a Muslim soldier and he had been appearing regularly in our hour of need.


In 1975 while in Singapore, i was on a road shoulder of a busy road waiting to cross and somehow i got so engrossed in my paath that i ddint realise i had stepped on the road and begun crossing..right in front of a speeding bus . . . suddenly i got such a strong “kick” that I went flying to the opposite side…safe and sound but shocked at a narrow escape..when i reached home . . . my dad was on the phone from Kuala Lumpur 250 miles away scolding me for being so careless . . . if not for Shaheed darshan Singh Ji he told me I would be history by now.


The last thing my dad told me before he left this world in 1984 was that a very major event is about to take place in Punjab and that he was going to join the shaheed faujaan as a nimana soldier . . . he had taken a hukmnama a week before and knew his end was near . . . just four weeks later Bluestar took place.


These are a few of my own personal experiences with this special aspect of “spiritual” life. as far as i know these are not “bhoots” or roohaan as we normally think of. They are special forces and they have their own rules and practises most of which are beyond our realm. Mostly they keep out of our way but on ocassion if help is warranted they do help. Thats all I caa say with conviction.


Dastaar for a Shaheed Singh
One day a middle aged Sikh came to our house. My mom gave him a siropa (dastaar) as present but he refused and said this siropa does not belong to him as the house is being guarded by shaheed singhs, and the person whom this should go to one day will come and get it from you.



An incident at Sri Harmandir Sahib
During a visit to Darbar Sahib, Amritsar I noticed the following things happening at Amrit Vela. The Sangat was finishing the last few minutes of Sukhmani Sahib, waiting for the doors to the cause way to be opened, when there was an instantaneous strong whirl wind accompanied by a drop in temperature, it went real icy even though moments before it was a hot and humid night. A couple of hours later, Guru Ji’s Saroop was being carried along the cause way to Darbar Sahib, again a strong wind occurred in seconds and the temperature plummeted dramatically. I noticed the pattern repeating over several days, same time, same place with the same changes. I was told the opening of the doors for the Sangat after Darbar Sahib’s Ishnan seva and Guru Sahib Ji’s arrival, are very important moments and protected by many Shaheed Singhs. The strong wind was caused by their arrival . . . and the purity of their souls was such that even the intense heat of the environment was cooled instantly by their presence.



Present at Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s Hazoori
A Singh I know used to do Sri Japjee Sahib roals for Akhand Paths early on, he had only just taken Amrit and the roles used to be the hard ones i.e. 12-2am, 2am-4am, etc. He used to get drowsy/sleepy whilst doing the roles and used to start seeing Singhs occurring and disappearing whilst walking up the red carpet to Maharaj’s Hazoori and this used to freak him out and keep him awake. At other times he used to actually see a Singh standing next to him (whilst on the role) with full bana and barsha (spear) in hand, this also used to send a chill down his spine and he used to start reading the Path with a renewed vigour and fear. After he narrated these experiences to a few Singhs they never ocuured again. The point of narrating this is not to argue in anyway the validity of doing Sri Japji Sahib roals, but rather to emphasise the presence of Shaheed Singhs in Maharaj’s Hazoori and especially in Sri Akhand Paths.



Clattering of hooves at Amritvela
At other times in Amrit Vela - the clattering of hooves of horses on stairs has awoken many Gursikhs. Maharaj awakes his Gursikhs himself.



Darshan of Shaheed Singhs in a dream
Imprisoned Gursikhs have told me how they feared what dire consequences they may undergo and questioned whether Shaheed Singhs would protect them. One of them told me that he had Darshan of 3 Shaheed Singhs in a dream (all 3 were in blue bana with Shastars), on the night he was imprisoned and he never feared anything whilst in jail as he knew the Shaheed Singhs would look after him.



Guru Gobind Singh Ji in command
1984 attack - recently a Kathavachak who has great knowledge of the movement narrated experiences of Operation Blue Star. He said during the attack a Singh was on top of Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib and he could see Sri Guru Gobind Singh at Darshan Deori - he shouted loudly and then narrated how Maharaj went to Darbar Sahib and paid his respects and upon return gave out chole bhatoore to the Singhs in battle. Maharaj himself is present in all major battles of Sikhs and Shaheed Fauja are present also, either in human form (born again for this purpose) or spiritual form.



The Power from Shaheed Singhs
There was a Rainsbhai Kirtan organised by the Jatha in 1998 - to commemorate the 20 years since 1978 (in Slough, UK). A lot of gifted Gursikhs were present in the Sangat and the majority of the Kirtan turned into Simran only. Some of the youth did not enjoy the Rainsbhia that much due it mostly being Simran - but a lot of the gifted Gursikhs felt that it was the Shaheed Singhs who created this atmosphere of Simran repitition.



At the Gates of Sachkhand
Once, a Sikh I know, went into a state of mind where he almost died. He hit the gates of Sachkhand, walking through a tunnel and came to a Light. When he saw the light he saw beautiful gardens and heard Gurbani! But then he saw so many Singhs in bana. He go scared so turned around. Then a spirit asked him where he was going (this was the spirit of Baba Deep Singh) he said, ‘Bhai Sahib you have won your place here, why are you turning away! These are the gates to Sachkhand. Then why are you outside?’ The spirit of Bhanda Singh Bahadur now rises and replies ‘We have not finished our duty. We wait to fight the battles for Khalsa Raj again! When it is established we will be there fighting for it too! We will be there to witness the day Khalsa has Victory!’



Protected from a stalker
I heard a story about a very Chardikala bibi who was coming back from the Gurdwara late at night. She saw a man standing infront of her with a knife. As she approached him he looked scared and backed off. A week later the man was caught by the police and arrested, being a murder suspect. The bibi was asked to come to the police station and identify him. She pointed him out and asked the officer if she could talk to the man. He said yes. She asked him, ‘When you saw me that night walking home alone, there was no one about, it was dark, you could have easily got away with it, so why didn’t you attack me?’ He replied, ‘Are you mad?! What about those two guys that were standing either side of you, in blue robes, holding massive swords longer than me! I didnt want to get killed! The bibi knew that she had been protected by the Shaheed Singhs.



Protection from being left behind
This happened on the day the Panth celebrated Guru Nanak Dev Jiis Prakash Dihara. I was sitting in Darbar for about two hours listening to katha/dhadi vaars and my parents were lookin for me but I never knew that. Suddenly, I had they urge to just get up and go to my car. when I went to my car, there were my parents in the car trying to leave but couldn’t. When I sat in, my mom asked me where I had been. I replied by saying i was ‘inside, upstairs in the main hall’. She said ‘We’ve been looking for you for about half an hour and we’ve been in the car for about 1/2 hour tryin to unlock the emergency brake but couldn’t.’ Then i tried and suddenly, very easily it opened. I think that it was Maharaj who was trying not to let my parents leave without me because thats what they were going to do.



Sourced from Tapoban Sahib

 

Gyani Jarnail Singh

Sawa lakh se EK larraoan
Mentor
Writer
SPNer
Jul 4, 2004
7,708
14,381
75
KUALA LUMPUR MALAYSIA
Yes - Gurbani supports the view that there are ghosts.

ਜਿਤੁ ਦਿਨਿ ਦੇਹ ਬਿਨਸਸੀ ਤਿਤੁ ਵੇਲੈ ਕਹਸਨਿ ਪ੍ਰੇਤੁ ॥
On that day when the body perishes-at that time, she becomes a ghost.

ਪਸੁ ਪ੍ਰੇਤ ਮੁਘਦ ਪਾਥਰ ਕਉ ਤਾਰੈ ॥
Even beasts, ghosts and the stone-hearted are saved.

ਕਈ ਕੋਟਿ ਭੂਤ ਪ੍ਰੇਤ ਸੂਕਰ ਮ੍ਰਿਗਾਚ ॥
Many millions are the evil-nature spirits, ghosts, pigs and tigers.

Sources (by line):

Ang 134 of SGGS, Ang 274, Ang 276, all by Guru Arjan Dev ji.

it just says "pathar"....meaning STONE (S)...where did the hearted come from ?? Added by the translator !!
IF the word "hearted" is accepted with the word STONE....then the SAME should apply to the preceeding words.... Then Pashu - Animal becomes..Person with animal birtees..animal like....greedy /lobhi like DOG..Sex Crazy..like the Elephant...etc etc..and those with "Ghost" like birtees... Its a FACT that there are LIVING HUMANS with...Animal Instints ruling them....also humans with Ghost instincts..and YES humans with hearts of Stone....AND YES>>ALL THESE HUMANS CAN BE SAVED !!!the bottom line is HUMANS.....MANUKH SREER.....not stones, not animals..not ghosts.... GURBANI is FOR LIVING HUMANS !!!
The Translator has LEFT the Bhoot pret animal etc alone and when he came to the STONE...he...decided that an "inanimate object like STONE..which has NO LIFE..couldnt be REBORN....so he looked around and settled on.."stone-HEARTED !!" he twisted the Gurbani to FIT ????
2. Scientists are even NOW "DISCOVERING".....that STONES are NOT INANIMATE after all...Many Life Forms in the Forms of CRYSTALS...stones etc..come to LIFE after being submerged in water..a "seemingly stone" dead object..is actually a LIVING THING....

Its NOT said in Vain..Gurbani is AGAADH BODH..too deep and too advanced for our simple "translations"....we just cannot twist it to FIT our feeble jigsaw puzzle...
 
Last edited by a moderator:

pk70

Writer
SPNer
Feb 25, 2008
1,582
627
USA
All above three Vakas are used in different contexts, it gives emotional disturbance to see people manipulating meaning based on just one Vaak(line). Translators add to misleading especially those who interpret line by line without understanding actually what is being said in the whole Guru Shabad.

On SGGS 134

It indicates a conviction of people, once a person dies, they rush to cremate the body and saying it can be a prêt (ghost) Otherwise different idea prevails in Guru Vaakas, in essence that who fall for others than the Creator, suffer, only Guru saves by giving awareness of the truth about the Creator

On SGGS 274

In here, the effect of His Naam is advocated that changes conscious and awareness of all kinds of people with all kinds of limitations and intentions, again ghost is not verified.

On SGGS276
Guru Vakas express His creation that includes all kinds described by different people as based on convictions or traditions; there is hint of a Devta( kinnar) that has different head than the body. Who has seen that? What does that tell? Guru ji wants to convey simple message that HE permeates in all, very close as well as far.
Gurbani is to set you free from all worries instead of infusing fears. Whatever people say, as per Guru, no need to fear if mind is set on Him and His refuge is taken as all is HIM.:)
 

Gyani Jarnail Singh

Sawa lakh se EK larraoan
Mentor
Writer
SPNer
Jul 4, 2004
7,708
14,381
75
KUALA LUMPUR MALAYSIA
ਜਿਤੁ ਦਿਨਿ ਦੇਹ ਬਿਨਸਸੀ ਤਿਤੁ ਵੇਲੈ ਕਹਸਨਿ ਪ੍ਰੇਤੁ ॥
On that day when the body perishes-at that time, she becomes a ghost.

Kehsan..means..say....meaning the people say...regard....it is accepted...
NO way is Kehasan to BECOME.....
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Randip Singh

Writer
Historian
SPNer
May 25, 2005
2,935
2,950
56
United Kingdom
I saw Ghost

The story was that a guy gets killed and he is not ready to go to the afterlife so he stays with his wife who cannot hear or see him, but one day the ghost goes to this crazy womans place and she hears and see's him and the ghost gets the crazy woman to talk to his wife, and it turn out it was the ghosts best friend that had him killed........:D
 

Randip Singh

Writer
Historian
SPNer
May 25, 2005
2,935
2,950
56
United Kingdom
Look bottom line and my view.

Ghosts and description of ghosts in Bani are used as metaphors.

The think we called Ghosts maybe some kind of transdimensional beings or some other phenomenon.

I think we are giving undue attention to the occult.

I reckon if you want to see a ghost then come to my house early in the morning and see me after 2 hours sleep, the sight will frighten you out of your skin. :)
 

Tejwant Singh

Mentor
Writer
SPNer
Jun 30, 2004
5,024
7,183
Henderson, NV.
One more way to see ghosts. All these actresses who look gorgeous with the make up on should be seen when they get up in the morning without the paint job.

Tejwant Singh
 
📌 For all latest updates, follow the Official Sikh Philosophy Network Whatsapp Channel:

Latest Activity

Top