• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Reply to thread

dear nrkalee


Its better if you start this debate that vishnu is the supreme lord and other hindu gods are

demi gods on hindu forum.i watched many hindu serials like om namoh shivay ,devi maa etc and one thing is clear that all worshippers of gods whether it is durga or shiv or vishnu

say that their god or goddess is supreme while others are demi gods.according to shaivaites vishnu is the worshipper of shiva and according to shakt vishnu is the worshipper of durga.so your claim that vedic literature accept vishnu the supreme lord is not fully true


as far as your claim that guru granth sahib is adulterated by bhai mani singh is absolutely baseless.you should know  the history of guru granth sahib before making such claims.

The original bir of aad granth known as kartarpuri bir which was written by guru arjan dev ji was in the possession of dhirtmallia.when guru gobind singh ji demanded it from him he refused to give it.then guru gobind singh ji exactly wrote the guru granth sahib adding shabads of guru tegh bahadur ji and one shalok of his.The  bir that guru gobind singh ji wrote is known as damdami bir.the gurgaddi was given to this bir.


     The kartar puri bir is still in the possession of sodhi family.a court case is going on

that this bir should be returned to sikhs.the people who read kartarpuri bir found that shabads of kartarpuri bir are not different from guru granth sahib of present.so there is no chance of bhai mani singh adultrating kartarpuri bir as well damdami bir.


Top