Reply to thread

Really ?? Do Hindus fall in love/get alienated simply by looking at the langauge ? The SINDHIS didnt get "alienated"..at all..not the least bit..they went ahead and PRINTED SGGS/GUTKAS etc in SINDHI LANGUAGE....many Sindhis i know memorised the entire SGGS and do sehaj paath akhand paaths all the time..the SINDHIS used to give Dowry in the form of a GUTKA of Nitnem written in SINDHI. The Famous Lawyer Raam jethmelani who has declared the Ram Chander as Bad Husband is one such SINDHI who has immense faith in the real Raam in SGGS...ADVANI the BJP President has been sued by his daughter in Law as one who THREW OUT HINDU IDOLS form his house....

There are actually SGGS copies availabe in HINDI DEVNAGREE SCRIPT !! are Hindus still alienated by that too...because the SCRIPT/Language doesn't CHANGE the MESSAGE - no idols, no devis, no devtas, no karva chauths, no rakhrrees, no holies, no diwlais, no fasts, no pilgrimages, no teeraths, almost EVERYTHING a HINDU has to perform Ritually is CONDEMNED by SGGS...and it wont change by changing it to English Malay or Arabic ?? The Goras in WEST read the Same MESSAGE in the English scripted SGGS !!

So we are barking up the wrong tree IF we say Hindus get alienated because of Punjabi....and Hindus will flock in the MILLIONS to become SIKHS of SGGS if we change the SCRIPT to DEVNAGREE ?? a pipe dream because the MESSAGE cant change..and Hindus cant change their habits..

Guru nanak ji throwing water to the WEST at KUMBH MELA Hardwaar...spoke verbally to the Millions of Hindus throwing water to the EAST- SUN ancestors...they didnt STOP ..not then..not today...can we assume that IF Guru Nanak ji had spoken in SHUDH SANSKRIT...things would be different ??  There are a couple of Pages of SHUDH SANSKRIT in the SGGS....just how many Hindus love those Pages and memorise them ???