Normal
Gyani ji, This is looking at glass half-empty approach. You acknowledge that there are Vaars and Kabits composed by Bhai Gurdaas ji. However you donot address the point, why did he compose them at all, when he knew that each of the Gurus upto Guru Arjan Dev ji have composed bani and made SGGS as one volume. And the importance of this question lies in the fact that the vaars contains information about the Guru Hargobind Sahib ji also. How do we establish that Guru Gobind singh was a polyglot is also being conviniently skipped? Once we had SGGS in place alongwith the Bani of Guru Tegh Bahadar sahib; what was the point that Guru Gobind Singh kept a company of 52 poets, specifically when SGGS was composed to its completion. the need to keep company with not less that 52 poets merit attention and also needs to be understood specifically when the threat from Mughals and Hinddu kings of the hills was always mounting!! Thanks!!Explorer
Gyani ji,
This is looking at glass half-empty approach.
You acknowledge that there are Vaars and Kabits composed by Bhai Gurdaas ji.
However you donot address the point, why did he compose them at all, when he knew that each of the Gurus upto Guru Arjan Dev ji have composed bani and made SGGS as one volume.
And the importance of this question lies in the fact that the vaars contains information about the Guru Hargobind Sahib ji also.
How do we establish that Guru Gobind singh was a polyglot is also being conviniently skipped?
Once we had SGGS in place alongwith the Bani of Guru Tegh Bahadar sahib; what was the point that Guru Gobind Singh kept a company of 52 poets, specifically when SGGS was composed to its completion.
the need to keep company with not less that 52 poets merit attention and also needs to be understood specifically when the threat from Mughals and Hinddu kings of the hills was always mounting!!
Thanks!!
Explorer
