• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Reply to thread

Some old sundar gutkas are known to have chaupai sahib. and those dates are probably when the baanis were recompiled in Dasam Granth. I still don't know why it took ~50 years for that 'effort'. and why didn't Guru Gobind Singh compile a bir in Hazoor Sahib itself? I expected that first bir would be saved there.

 

I think this controversy can never be solved (regarding dasam granth and authenticity) and will only keep on dividing the Panth further. we should all do sangat of Guru, listen to Kirtan. if we do dasam baani paaths on our own, its ok, just like people do different meditations, jaaps, paaths etc. if you meet someone who doesn't believe in Dasam Granth, don't get surprised and don't be offended.


Top