Reply to thread

Ambarsaria ji

"Sikhs can and will carry lot of other stuff too as the times change. Whether this will be a replacement for Kirpan or a Kirpan with hidden electronics or other ammunition, only time will tell."

Its clear Kirpan cannot be replaced. Its vital for preparation of Karah Parshad and Amrit. The moment a Sikh takes off his Kirpan and adopts some other weapon he ceases to Sikh. You cannot go against Hukam from Panj Piare, which is Hukam form Guru Gobind Singh ji. We cannot just 'replace' Kakars they are gifts from Satguru Gobind Singh ji. 

We can use modern weapons but that does not mean we have to modify our current kakars. We can wear Kirpan in gatra while also holding a gun, axe etc.

Kakars will never grow old. A Gursikh wearing Dastar with Kirpan and Full Kesh will always be an amazing sight, even one million years from now. Gursikh roop is niara (seperate) and always will be, such is the bakshsish of Guru Gobind Singh ji.

I believe baata for preparation of Amrit and Karah Parshad should be made of Sarbloh in addition to Kirpan. However this is not relevant to discussion.