Reply to thread

Gogi ji

In your profile you say you are agnostic. How then does it happen that your essay on this thread is so deeply inspiring?  It is thoughtful. I put off reading your essay until my mind was clear enough to really concentrate on the arguments you were making. You took on a big job-- going beyond repetition of sources and asking fundamental theological questions, and then finally showing how the Sikh faith answers those questions in a distinctive way. The essay is truly the product of a disciplined mind. You really have managed to take my understanding to a deeper level by connecting ideas and focusing on the implications of the Guru's words for all those many different aspects of the religious experience. It all makes sense, all falls together, is framed in terms of the Guru's own words, and suggests serious training in philosophy. How long did it take you to write this?

(and only with humor, are you an agnostic Jesuit?)

God is always cheerful