• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Reply to thread

Gurfateh

 

Few more inputs.

1) in Areas where we have Halal only,we can kill animal bird ourselves.So if Bhai Raj visit Delhi again or das goes to Indore Das will teach him how to carry out Jhataka.

2)It is not to do with Nihungs only. other grups are SInghs of Deccan and Assam/Kablis/Iranis/Bhatras/Sikalkars/Labanas/Ranghretas.They have langer of Jhataka also.

3)If some one being a Sikh is afraid of seing animal being killed or not sharing the food with those amritdharis who eat meat.Das recomends them  as per Nihung treditions to join Radha Swamis or Dera Sacha Sauda.

4)As per Bebeck in nihungs also taking meat is not encouraged,yet that is more to do with Dera Dars who do not work.For outcaste/tribals,who work as lot and are acutal sikhs since making of Khalsa PAnth.They need meat as food,to repair the broken muscle due to the heavy labour or for instant source of enregy.

5)If das accuses anti Dasham Granth Sahib guys are emblam bearer of Bhappaism as they could not understand the mental state of outcaste(which Tenth Master understood well as he had both Bhai Jaita and Sangta as his childhood play mates at Patna Sahib),ritualistic Jathas or Sants,totaly oblivious to living conditions of outcastes/poors talk of anti meat and other ritualism and that is best example of jattism(as being from the family jaats on paternal side das is aware that meat is big no in them due to thier being Vaisya).Such pagan  thing is not acceptalbe.

 

LAstly Tenth Master said and is recorded in Sau Sakhi.Mam Sikh Mas Khai Dij Nahi.It is my Sikh who eats meat and Brahmins do not.(Das is ready to tell the whole stroy about this).

6)If some one does not eat meat,he/she has a full right to not to eat and propogate.But it is right for meat eater to keep his views also.

7) we can have fish and pork also packaged as both can never be halaled.

8)das found no prolbem to us non halal beef while he was in action.(There are three instance in Shri Dasham Granth Sahib,where sacrifce of cow or hunt is given).Only thing is that is we want to replace petrolium with animal dung fuel,then there could be reason to protect the cow.Yet for Sikhs not eating beef is not a religeous duty as such.


Top