Dear brother, as per my knowledge, the book "Gurbani Paath Darshan" has been written by Gurbachan Singh ji himself so who added those adjectives?. Even if we put aside the issue of adding so many adjectives to own name-what about other things that are written in that book? Who wrote those useless things in the book "Gurbani Paath Darshan"? I cannot believe a person who has the understanding of Gurbani can write those things. And now leave that also aside and read "Gurmukh Prakash". I am pretty sure you will never have doubt again on the points raised by Prof. Inder Singh.
I dont understand why its so hard to see those wrong doings??
My veer, if you still have doubts I can give you the page numbers in those books and you can go and see them yourself.
?????....huh!. what?
.....??????
.....and now my Veer go ahead and read the books written by those people whom the Sikhs drove away from Punjab, I am pretty sure they will write things even more fascinating.
....??? Veerji, Gurmat accepts what is right and logical without caring who said that and from which faith that is coming. At the same time Gurmat rejects what is superstition and useless ritual regardless what faith it belongs to. Therefore, I do not see any point in measuring the nearness or farness of Gurmat from anything else.
...... Useless effort to bring Polygamy to Sikhism, have you seen the plight of Muslim women who are suffering due to this polygamy thing? Go and ask those women if they themselves believe in polygamy. In fact, years back in India, the muslim women were asking the Indian Government to mend the laws and ban polygamy (which is allowed only to muslims in India). I forgot that documentary's name which was specially compiled by a social worker, otherwise I could have cited the name for your reference.
In todays world, not a single man can do justice with more then one wife in terms of discharging his duties towards them. Do you think Gurbani will ever promote injustice to women???.... ah pardon me!
Can you jusfity here what you mean regarding polygamy?
..well my friend that is your own conclusion.
..I hope to be there and hope to find time to be on each and every thread some day.
????. who is fabricating the past? and how?
No logical thinking Sikh will ever agree that their beloved Guru Gobind Singh ji ever wrote the whole part of Dasam Granth. I have immense respect and love for Guru Gobind Singh ji. I cannot believe anybody who has the slighest understanding of Sikhism and Guru Gobind Singh ji can ever think that all what Dasam Granth has in it today was written by Guru Gobind Singh ji. .....Forgive me please! .....I am totally hurt by what people are doing to Guru Gobind Singh ji. Use some brain my brothers!
?????....Again, I do not believe all part of Dasam Granth is Guru Gobind Singh ji's work.
Convince me.
what??
Again.....what are you trying to say??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sat Shri Akaal,
-Akashdeep
"A lot of reading without contemplation will not be of any use, mind
will still be thoughtless. What good is the water for the roots, which
cannot be absorbed. And a thoughtless mind is like a balloon, wanders
aimlessly and eventually falls down."
