Reply to thread

seeker3k ji

I have to step in here at the risk of agitating you or anyone else in the conversation. Forgive me if I am interrupting the flow of thought. However this conversation is getting very difficult to follow. And seeker3k ji -- no one is even thinking of banning you or dismissing your point of view. The problem is that many of us are having a hard time making the same connections that you are making from point to point. 

It would help if you would re-group as they say in the military. Pull in and re-organize your argument. We would like to be able to follow what you are saying. It has nothing to do with your English which is better than you think. 

Please restate your thinking on the following points. Don't explain but just restate and then maybe we can put the rest of it together. 

Here are the points

1. Your understanding of Guru Nanak as a human being and as a leader of the Sikh panth.

2. Your understanding of Guru Nanak's contribution to spirituality.

3. Your understanding of Guru Nanak's way to union with the Creator.

4. Your understanding of the value of the shabads composed by Guru Nanak in leading others to a more truthful life.

That will do to start. It would really help a lot if you could just tell us what you think on each of those points.