Reply to thread

Isn't 'following your own mind' and not SGGS the same as misinterpreting SGGS, especially when it's being interpreted to be referring only to the one thing that it shouldn't be - the mind??

 

Good... because I didn't mean to offend you... I am just trying to fully understand your position. 

So then, if you agree that you do not know... you can't entirely dismiss those of us who who have had such experiences. Not knowing, or not experiencing it for yourself is not the same as outright disbelief. Am I understanding your position correctly?

And if this is true, then surely you can think that maybe possibly that SGGS could have both messages in the same shabad, using the same words and the same metaphors... could not both messages be in there... one pertaining to life on the physical plane, and also message pertaining to spiritual realization? Certainly that would not seem 'too' far fetched when we are as you said, supposed to live by both aspects of miri and piri?

Remember, that I have never dismissed that SGGS may have some meaning pertaining to the physical existence... I always said that BOTH messages are perhaps there, and that it was written that way on purpose.