Reply to thread

Gurmukh balbir singh ji,

pray and say Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.

 

IS it "really essential" that only the writing of "Gurbani" is proof of JYOT being transferred ?? I think NOT. Jyot is the "philosophy" that Guru nanak Ji propogated and the other Gurus carried it along and Now this philosophy is in the SGGS.

IF we go by your arguments..then the Guru of Guru Amardass Ji is ONLY "Guru Angad Ji"....since Guru nanak ji never gave Guru Amardass Ji gurgadee ?? Thus each Guru becomes successor of only "one" Guru ???

In a Mala of Pearls...which "pearl" is the first one and which is the last one ?? Are the pearls more important or the Thread ?? In a circle where is the beginning and the end...

SHABAD GURU is PRIMAL...Akal Purakh....and Guru nanak ji declared this fact in Sidh ghost...this "thread" hold all the Gurus in one Mala...at one end is Guru nanak ji and at the other end is SGGS..no one cna say this"Guur" comes first and that "Guru" comes last....it is a complete CIRCLE..no end no beginning...I hope my light is burning ?

Gyani jarnail Singh