- Jan 31, 2011
- 5,769
- 8,194
- 55
Why create a fuss over it ? Dukh Bhanjani sahib is just a collection of baanis from SGGS , various shabads relating to mercy of god in curing our ailments, physical , mental and spiritual .
because not everyone believes that this is the case, yes, embracing the bani will always help, but believing in miracles is to upset the very fabric of life, not all Sikhs believe this, if you do, that is wonderful, but a balanced view is always good for the reader.
Its just baani . Lets not forget that it is human tendency we only go to guru most of the times when we're sad or in pain "dukh" .
Again, do not speak for the whole of humanity, in the face of death some 16 times, I have never once asked for the Gurus help, at that point, it is too late, I did not do what you asked of me, so I have got myself in a situation facing death, any chance of upsetting the laws of physics and medicine to give me a hand? I promise next time I really will do the right stuff and not get myself in this situation again!
So , sometimes people start doing paath of baani to gain confidence and hope in god .
Again, I understand this, but it is not for everyone.
I see something different, faith in the naam, make your actions consistent with such, take the consequences like a man and with full acceptance. Acceptance is pretty big in Sikhism in my view, a good Sikh does not beg, even the supreme, for anything, it is taken on the chin.
"Whosoever afflicted with a disease , either a gursikh or any believer in Guru Nanak , should wake up at amritvela and after nitnem do this paath for 40 days . If not possible to do paath, he should get it listened to. Having faith in Guru Nanak , I guarantee it will help you"
Well, again, in my opinion, it is statements like this that ensure Sikhism remains a religion of superstition rather than pragmatism. But again, if it works for you I have complete respect for that, and wish you well.
Anyways, on a related note, there's the old desi habit of vowing of 40 days paath.
Some people call it karm -kaand , I say it takes 40 days to built a habit .
now that I agree with, I think habit building is a good constructive path, provided one can see it for embracing rather than blind repetition to achieve a personal agenda.
Lol , ask someone who wakes up at 8 in the morning to wake up at 4 am for 40 continuous days for sukhmani sahib. Easier said than done !
but should it be like that? why should it be easier said than done, it should be the easiest thing in the world if the love is there, surely?
The saakhi is of Bibi Rajni , a pious and believing woman who was married off to a leper by her angry father , because he thought she was an ungrateful wretch .
She accepted her fate .
but not her husbands?
Long story cut short , her crippled leper husband saw a black crow take a dip in amrit sarovar (harmandir sahib was not present back then) and come out as white. He took a dip and got cured . It was a beautiful small lake surrounded by beautiful forest .
do you not think this story focuses more on blind faith rather than learning, which is the true goal of a Sikh? how many millions of cripples currently wither away having tried this, only to then face the fact that not only are they crippled, but their god does not love them enough to do the same, that their faith is not strong enough, that such miracles do exist, but not for them, is quite a heavy cross to bear given an already existing physical affliction, the added mental torture is unfair and should not be there, it is for those I think I write this as I do.