i have hard time finding the posts. i can only find the ones which come on my e mail. here i will explain the writing balancing etc. question here is if u know about these subjects, then it will be useful note if not then like any other critic will come and ask again. There are four parts to the compositon. 1, writing, 2 kaasad or balancing, 3 composing, 4 singing.
other than the gurbani as the sikhs claim there is no other good composition which has been written, balanced , composed and sung by the same person. The sikh belief is that the seven gurus who wrote sggs knew all and did everything. let me say here when satta and balwand refused to sing in congregation then guru arjun dev je sang himself in simple tunes. Next there were 35 other writers who wrote in sggs their writing is also balanced and composed in all the 30 or 31 classical tunes. does it mean that guru Arjun dev jee did that especially when he himself sang in simple tunes in the congregation. it points out to someone else. next part of balancing is arabic; it implies one starts singing and if there is a short fall for the continuation of the tune it is adjusted by the kaasad. Thatg is how the sggs is being sung from ages on. the indian balancing is the count of lagaan and magraans which i will not go into it. doing so the singing is like the saa re gaama etc. if someone thinks that sggs is ever sung like this then i might be wrong. here I want to say that if u have any underzstanding of this system then we can go further otherwise it is just curiosity. so long brohter. if u want some spirituality then read my heer sayal either on APNA gurmukhi books or kitaabaan . spiritualy is everywhere even in heer there is spirituality.
other than the gurbani as the sikhs claim there is no other good composition which has been written, balanced , composed and sung by the same person. The sikh belief is that the seven gurus who wrote sggs knew all and did everything. let me say here when satta and balwand refused to sing in congregation then guru arjun dev je sang himself in simple tunes. Next there were 35 other writers who wrote in sggs their writing is also balanced and composed in all the 30 or 31 classical tunes. does it mean that guru Arjun dev jee did that especially when he himself sang in simple tunes in the congregation. it points out to someone else. next part of balancing is arabic; it implies one starts singing and if there is a short fall for the continuation of the tune it is adjusted by the kaasad. Thatg is how the sggs is being sung from ages on. the indian balancing is the count of lagaan and magraans which i will not go into it. doing so the singing is like the saa re gaama etc. if someone thinks that sggs is ever sung like this then i might be wrong. here I want to say that if u have any underzstanding of this system then we can go further otherwise it is just curiosity. so long brohter. if u want some spirituality then read my heer sayal either on APNA gurmukhi books or kitaabaan . spiritualy is everywhere even in heer there is spirituality.
