- Jan 31, 2011
- 5,769
- 8,194
- 55
.a Real Sikh is he/she who comes to learn and not teach [rules me out]. Who better than you Sir Harry, when it comes to learning, a model student. You are a true Sikh who stands on an unmovable "path" [Sikh the learner]. It is not the strongest, nor the intelligent but the most responsive to accept change and you have it.
Everything I have learned has been through fire and brimstone, scars stop you making the same mistakes again and again, and is much more effective than theology, in my opinion (see what I did there), learning is quite painful for me, I have to be bloodied and bruised before I do, I live and learn through life, I thought that made me a Sikh once, but the absence of any theology negates that, lets say I live by certain Sikh values that are universal.
Oh I do, only too well, Sikhism is Sikh Philosophy diluted by tradition and cultureI hope one day you will understand the difference between Sikhism and Philosophy - you will unquestionably fall in love with the wisdom of your forefathers - who were Sikhs and always will be Sikhs.
I can, and have provided links to respected people within the Sikh community that would disagree with you, I won't because it gets us nowhere, you will have to accept that the above is not the only way lauded by Sikhism..much of what I write can be cross-checked with my Guru [SGGSJ]. I only translate n interpret Gurbani consistent with the teachings of Guru Granth and Guru Panth. As I said earlier, my forefathers lived in a society and at a time when belief in afterlife was rife. Europeans call it reincarnation, transmigration; we call it janam janam [see today's hukamnama]. And of course, we've evolved from having a bird brain to a King Singh 1.
Yes, you mentioned this when we met, as I munched your mangoes, (that is not a euphemism), I resent the use of the word coconut, although I know it is not an insult, more a statement of fact, your saying I am white inside, and brown outside, take a good look at our motherland next time you go home, from what I hear, I am an amateur, India, Punjab is becoming is actually to western for me, its more western than the west, so happens when the coconuts become mainstream? its already happening, look at the news, the tv, our homeland is one big coconut. As it happens, I resent the term because my inside is neither white nor brown, I never embraced british culture anymore than I embraced Indian culture, I just wanted to know the truth, whatever colour it was, I respect your desire to police this, you will not be offended if I therefore police you. After all someone has to police the police, no?.no, not at all. Only trying to protect n preserve the teachings of my forefathers. Coconuts like you and my own children [some of them] will dilute it beyond recognition if not policed.
..no that's not true, he's a beautiful soul who has his own agenda. Besides, you can't serve two masters, I can only serve SGGSJ, the "original" with 1430 pages and I obey my Panth, albeit, needing constitutional reform. He's divorced them both.
and I am sure he feels exactly the same as you, with the same feelings regarding divorce, so who are we to believe? but its not about that, everyone should be able to put their point forward without running to convenient one liners that may possibly have incorrect translations, and have been invariably taken out of context from the entire essence of what they may have been trying to portray.
..Guru Gobind Singh, after losing His four sons in the name of Sikhi, was tormented by His wife mata ji Sundari, thus: "where are my sons ?" to which he replied, "char mua toa kiya huya jeevat kai hazaar" [translation - so what if you've lost four, thousand will be born]. You, I and others are His sons/daughters, Gobind Singh have therefore, reincarnated.
that is not definitive, that is another way to justify your stance, I asked how it worked, with respect, not another soundbite, so how does it work, can you explain the mechanics, again, I am not being twee, I want to know, you get born, you do stuff, you die, fill in the blanks.,
...Hindu, if you ask me is a derogatory term coined by the minor Asia lot [Arabs] to socially segregate the early ethic communities living in and around River Indus as inferior sub-species. From an ideological perspective, the theory of reincarnation both compliments and corroborates with the workings of Nanak's AP. It provides the necessary time span for the scales of justice to be balanced, since clearly such does not always occur in a single life. And Nanak's reincarnation answers with simple clarity n precision the most complex questions: "why do bad things happen to good people ?" along with the converse, "why do good things happen to bad people ?". Nanak answers beautifully, "karmi apo apni" [you reap what you saw]. This dovetails neatly into theoretical thinking [reincarnation]. That is to say, what we are today is the result of our yesterdays, meaning past lives.
what about pigs? bring the animals into this, before we go any further, but thank you for starting.
Sikh is a distinct and unique religion that was "revealed" not found nor created, but revealed to young Nanak because evolution [God] deemed it critical for the inhabitants of Indus Valley civilization to survive the onslaught of the barbaric conquering Moslems. Sikhs own India and not just Khalistan.
this is a classic case in point, now this is your opinion, and its a good opinion, not as good as the opinion that I do actually look like Dolph Lungdren, now that is a good opinion, but yours is good too, however, "[God] deemed it critical for the inhabitants of Indus Valley civilization to survive the onslaught of the barbaric conquering Moslems. Sikhs own India and not just Khalistan." I mean how do you know? Do you speak to God? actually don't answer that, it will just make things worse, but you can see where I am coming from, your speaking for God............
.good question ! scan your body for a mo - and - tell me, what part resembles mum n what part resembles dad ? They've already reincarnated - as handsome H. Its you bro, which body you gonna move into ? Nanak wants to give you a spiritual body, that is, "nam dhan". But when you're read
uhm you didn't answer the question, I suppose my head does look a bit like a baby elephants butt now my hair has gone, but could you just answer the question?