Fools Who Wrangle Over Flesh

Harsimran Singh · Nov 10, 2008

WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh!

"No, I am asking, "How does one perform jhatka with a bow and arrows?" - Bhagat Singh

As far as I know, Guru Ji also kept swords(shastar vidya), by which Jhatka can be easily applied.

WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh!
Harsimran Singh Khalsa

Randip Singh · Nov 10, 2008

Harsimran Singh said:
WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh!

"No, I am asking, "How does one perform jhatka with a bow and arrows?" - Bhagat Singh

As far as I know, Guru Ji also kept swords(shastar vidya), by which Jhatka can be easily applied.

WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh!
Harsimran Singh Khalsa

But how do you do Jkatka on an animal running away with an arrow?

BhagatSingh · Nov 10, 2008

Re: The Sikh Religon And Eating Meat

Sikh religion and meating eating eh? hmm...

*evil music - dun dun dun*

Meat is bad, vegetables are bad because we are killing living things! SO we must survive by eating AIR! :yes:
NOW THAT is the Sikh way of life.

NO WAIT... by eating air we kill stuff... NOOOOOO...

we must survive by eating nothing and holding our breath!!
NOW THAT is the SIKH way of life. :happy:

wait a second.... wait just a darn second here... by doing that we kill ourselves! NOOOO....
NOW THAT is the SIKH way of life! or should I say death...

*evil music - dun dun dun climax point*
no comments!! NO QUESTIONS!! :}--}:
NOW THAT is the REAL Sikh way of life!

Case closed.

*evil music stops - dun dun dun*

Brought to you by the Sikh Way of Life deciders. Our motto: we make rules you FOLLOW THEM!!:yes:

Archived_Member4 · Nov 10, 2008

randip singh said:
But how do you do Jkatka on an animal running away with an arrow?

The Gurus, if they killed an animal with an arrow then it was done the jhatka way, there is no doubt here. To answer yours and BhagatSingh question how its done in general sense, well ask someone who as done it, go to a hunting site do some research; thats what i recommend. The way the Gurus did it is with there ability to shot an arrow.

BhagatSingh · Nov 10, 2008

singh said:
the gurus, if they killed an animal with an arrow then it was done the jhatka way, there is no doubt here. To answer yours and bhagatsingh question how its done in general sense, well ask someone who as done it, go to a hunting site do some research; thats what i recommend. The way the gurus did it is with there ability to shot an arrow.

hahaha :happy:

you cracked me up!

Archived_Member4 · Nov 11, 2008

BhagatSingh said:
hahaha :happy:

you cracked me up!

Whats so funny about my post????

kds1980 · Nov 11, 2008

Dear KDS 1980,
"Then the question is why was halal banned and hunting was not?" - KDS 1980

I am not a hunter, but from my best guess, I think hunting was not banned and halaal was banned on the basis of cruelty. You are right, hunting can be creul, it depends on how you kill the animal. If the Guru ever hunted then I am sure they killed the animal with the "Jhatka" method which we know is not considered creul, and that is why the Gurus did not ban hunting versus Halaal.

My mother's family live in Assam and Hunting was quite reguler in their house.I too in my teens shot some birds and read plenty about hunting.Hunting cannot be compared to jhatka from any point It involves cruelity even without any intention

Also What about Fish.Taking her out of water and killing it is also not humane.In terms of cruelity Killing fish or Hunting is worse than halal .Then why these things are not banned?

In mY views there several Things that could be behind this ban of halal

1) It is sacrifice

2) It is intentionally Giving animal suffering in the name of god

3)Muslims were forcing each and everybody to consume halal meat

ekonkar89 · Nov 11, 2008

Just earlier I've read some interesting information posted by Singh Ji, why is it not visible to viewers anymore?.

Other than that, there were also other replies, which are not visible anymore?
- Why have these posts been deleted?

Randip Singh · Nov 11, 2008

ekonkar89 said:
Just earlier I've read some interesting information posted by Singh Ji, why is it not visible to viewers anymore?.

Other than that, there were also other replies, which are not visible anymore?
- Why have these posts been deleted?

All off topic posts, including my replies have been deleted.

Randip Singh · Nov 11, 2008

aad0002 said:
Randip ji

Yes

Too bad we Punjabi's are not that far sighted!

Randip Singh · Nov 12, 2008

Re: The Sikh Religon And Eating Meat

Suntink said:
My opinion is look “God wouldn’t give out bad karmas to someone who eats meat, instead to the caring, loving mother who cooks a good meal with meat which is often much harder to prepare he would reward her in whatever way he could.”

I love the way you have put that!

Randip Singh · Nov 12, 2008

Re: The Sikh Religon And Eating Meat

BhagatSingh said:
Sikh religion and meating eating eh? hmm...
*evil music - dun dun dun*

Meat is bad, vegetables are bad because we are killing living things! SO we must survive by eating AIR! :yes:
NOW THAT is the Sikh way of life.

NO WAIT... by eating air we kill stuff... NOOOOOO...

we must survive by eating nothing and holding our breath!!
NOW THAT is the SIKH way of life. :happy:

wait a second.... wait just a darn second here... by doing that we kill ourselves! NOOOO....
NOW THAT is the SIKH way of life! or should I say death...

*evil music - dun dun dun climax point*
no comments!! NO QUESTIONS!! :}--}:
NOW THAT is the REAL Sikh way of life! Case closed.

*evil music stops - dun dun dun*

Brought to you by the Sikh Way of Life deciders. Our motto: we make rules you FOLLOW THEM!!:yes:

Hahah!

BhagatSingh · Nov 13, 2008

Singh said:
Whats so funny about my post????

lol, here's why...

the gurus, if they killed an animal with an arrow then it was done the jhatka way, there is no doubt here.

Jhatka is decapitating the animal in one swift blow. It is IMPOSSIBLE to do jhatka with an arrow!! An arrow usually bleeds the animal to death.

BhagatSingh · Nov 13, 2008

Re: The Sikh Religon And Eating Meat

randip singh said:
Hahah!

Archived_Member4 · Nov 13, 2008

BhagatSingh said:
lol, here's why...

Jhatka is decapitating the animal in one swift blow. It is IMPOSSIBLE to do jhatka with an arrow!! An arrow usually bleeds the animal to death.

Here's the part you didnt get Bhagatsingh. Guru ji is the shooter of the arrow. :yes:

Sinister · Nov 13, 2008

Singh said:
Here's the part you didnt get Bhagatsingh. Guru ji is the shooter of the arrow. :yes:

In translation; "you dont need logic and reason when the 'paramatma' is on your side".

c h e e r s

pk70 · Nov 13, 2008

Sinister said:
In translation; "you dont need logic and reason when the 'paramatma' is on your side".

c h e e r s

Sinister ji, with all due respect to your rationality, you haven’t understood Mr. Singh Ji’s statement, a little hint I can give here to understand him, it is about Guru’s having extreme accuracy in archery, that kind of accuracy even today is also witnessed. Hitting on some parts of the body, death occurs instantly. If still you want to drag it, enjoy

BhagatSingh · Nov 13, 2008

Sinister said:
In translation; "you dont need logic and reason when the 'paramatma' is on your side".

c h e e r s

*sigh*

BhagatSingh · Nov 13, 2008

pk70 said:
Sinister ji, with all due respect to your rationality, you haven’t understood Mr. Singh Ji’s statement, a little hint I can give here to understand him, it is about Guru’s having extreme accuracy in archery, that kind of accuracy even today is also witnessed. Hitting on some parts of the body, death occurs instantly. If still you want to drag it, enjoy

On what parts exactly? Maybe we can tell our muslim brothers to shove the knife in that part and kill the animal outright...

pk70 · Nov 13, 2008

BhagatSingh said:
On what parts exactly? Maybe we can tell our muslim brothers to shove the knife in that part and kill the animal outright...

Muslim brothers are the last ones to listen to us