Re: Guru Nanak was a 'false' Prophet ??
Guru Nanak as the remaining nine Sikh Gurus NEVER claimed to be "prophets" and were NOT Prophets...in the same way as the Jewish/Christian/Muslim prophets.
The SIKH GURUS were GURUS -TEACHERS...of the PATH to GOD.....and the GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE is the SHABAD GURU...the WORD that has existed from Time Immemeorial as with GOD.
The GURU GRANTH JI doesnt contain any "prophecies", "miracles" stories and tales about men and so called "prophets", cheating and lying, murdering and stealing, burning and destroying, pillaging and genocide...ALL GURU GRANTH contains are LOVE for GOD...The WAY to GOD..the PERFECT human being and How he loves GOD...and GURU GRANTH doesnt Limit itself to JUST "MY OWN"... this is as UNIVERSAL as GOD HIMSELF.... IF GOD is for all mankind..and all mankind are brothers... then GURU GRANTH is the UNIVERSAL PATH that teaches this Brotherhood of man...an GIVES place of HONOUIR to Hindus, Muslims, others who reached the Path to GOD in their OWN WAY.
Prphets that keep coming and coming is in it self a positive PROOF that the earlier "prophet" FAILED in his Task and God had to send another..after having seen this mohd(pbuh) decided to end all this and declare himself the LAST..just as Jesus had declared Himself the SON of GOD.
GOD is PERFECT and His Prophet should be PERFECT....if another had to come then this so called Prophet is not perfect..
Whatever is in the Bible is also in the ancient Babylonian pagan writings...SAME STORIES and miracles etc...and the Koran took all this wholesale and imported it...so it cant be revealed because it already EXISTS earlier.
However the GURBANI is ORIGINAL...written as it is revelaed and only ONCE..and most importantly written down by its authors.... the comment by some that Guur Arjun Ji wrote Guru nanak Ji's bani is wrong...GURU NANAK Ji and GURU ANGAD Ji and GURU Amardass Ji and Guru ramdass Ji WROTE their own GURBANI...Guur Angad Ji just compiled it all into ONE Place - the GRANTH JI. Later on guru Teg bahadur Ji's bani was written down by Guru Gobind Singh ji.
SIKHI is ORIGINAL...and One of its KIND....NO copies exist.
jarnail Singh
