Harry ji
It is only magic if one does not understand the trick. (though the trick must still be performed even after it is understood, otherwise what use is there in understanding it) Once you understand that the magician had the bunny in the hat all along, is it still magic?
The trick is that opening up to a random page and selecting a shabad is more likely to bring the attention of the reader to the shabad, and that which the shabad describes/prescribes. This conscious awareness of the shabad then becomes the grounding conscious awareness throughout the day.
As SP ji says, the essence of all shabad is "waheguru waheguru waheguru..." the grounding conscious awareness.
It is magic when the trick works out correctly. It is true that you have the bunny, the conscious awareness all along and that you could simply pull the bunny out of any old hat, any ritual. You may choose to follow this traditional ritual or you may choose to follow your own rituals. But to pull the bunny out of this one hat specifically is tradition and it brings people together in congregations.
And you know the importance of congregations...
PS A friend your age suggested that I stick to art but I want to get better with analogies and figurative language. It's fun! Hope this one made more sense to you.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mysticism <-- check this out too.
I thought about this thread till the early hours, the argument I was trying to make was that there was enough pragmatic information in the SGGS to explain most things, I have now come up with rational explanations for most of the Sikhi traditions, hair, booze, etc, and everything makes a sense without even a tiny drop of spiritualism or mysticism, however, although I live life pretty much as I wish, and balance that with an attempt to enrich Creation with as of my input as I can, and that is my life, but there is something missing, a void that never gets filled, I attempt to smooth it over with help from the five thieves, but as I start filling it, it empties, filling a void like this with the thieves help is a pointless and destructive task, yet, to embrace the mystical and spiritual aspect of Sikhism, which would be the logical next step, is closed to me, why? and it is this question I asked myself last night, Why is this step closed to me, surely it could be the most enriching thing I have ever discovered about Sikhism, Surely it is the icing on the cake, to have a full and strong connection established in my head to the essence, so Why not?
The answer is easy, it is fear, I fear the connection, and I fear it because as soon as I have that connection, then me, Harry, must die, the personality that I am, can not continue if this connection goes ahead, for most of my lifestyle would not be in line with a complete connection, I would certainly become the person I wish to be, but that person is so far away from who I am, that who I am would cease, and I do not wish to die just yet, I like having the thieves round for a good old party, not often, but sometimes, it is only to my self that I behave like this, to others I am a good sikh, but I am not to myself, so there it is, Fear.........