I Feel That A Lot Of Sikh's Are Spiritually Dead

[Dalvinder Singh Grewal]

Sri Guru Granth Sahib is not Eternal, to treat it to the equivalence of God is....
It was written by Holy Men of God with inspiration through Guru Nanak's mission.
An object cannot be eternal, if you are trying to say in this world, then their would be evidence of this before Sikhism was, and their is not.
Now The Wonderful Counselor/Teacher (Waheguru), whom taught Guru Nanak a lot, is Eternal, as through him we receive instruction in order to qualify to meet the Mighty One.
Like Guru Nanak said - 'Become like King of Kings, says Nanak' page 25 Japji Sahib

Sri Guru Granth Sahib is Guru eternal since it shall ever be the Guru of Sikhs and no human being hereafter shall be accepted as the living Guru. Guru Nanak was not the guiding light to all the gurus and saint contributors of Sri Guru Granth sahib. Baba Farid, Bhagat Kabir, Namdev and many other contributors were not under the influence of Guru Nanak. A word of truth received direct from God is considered as the word revealed. The Truthful essence of the banis of contributors of leaves no doubt that it was the word revealed.

 

[Theologian.]

Sri Guru Granth Sahib is Guru eternal since it shall ever be the Guru of Sikhs and no human being hereafter shall be accepted as the living Guru. Guru Nanak was not the guiding light to all the gurus and saint contributors of Sri Guru Granth sahib. Baba Farid, Bhagat Kabir, Namdev and many other contributors were not under the influence of Guru Nanak. A word of truth received direct from God is considered as the word revealed. The Truthful essence of the banis of contributors of leaves no doubt that it was the word revealed.

What do you mean eternal, it cannot be eternal. Look up the definition sir.
I never said anyone after Guru Nanak should be accepted as a living Guru.
Guru Nanak was the light to Sikhism and inspiration to some of the Gurus, just to be clear you do deny this?
What do you mean by word revealed? How do you view it to have been fully revealed?

 

[Sikhilove]

What do you mean eternal, it cannot be eternal. Look up the definition sir.
I never said anyone after Guru Nanak should be accepted as a living Guru.
Guru Nanak was the light to Sikhism and inspiration to some of the Gurus, just to be clear you do deny this?
What do you mean by word revealed? How do you view it to have been fully revealed?

Gyan is the Guru, the Guru is the Gyan.

It's the Gyan that is Guru Granth Sahib Ji, we bow to the Gyan. The Gyan is eternal- because it's the Gyan of Truth