I get your point totally. It does seem inappropriate to say ' I am khalsa' or he is khalsa, she isn't!! Then again, it is still inappropriate to call someone khalsa, when they have visible faults or you know that the purity is not there.
What I was trying to say was to help eliminate this very issue, which is why I called it the brotherhood and referenced it is a rebirth and new family of equal brothers and sisters.- This way, when one takes amrit, or is baptised, they then become MEMBERS of the khalsa.
Object of all members of this khalsa, the Guru's khalsa, is to become and maintain your TRUE PURITY to the MAXimum level possible.
Like you say, we can refer to them as students if it makes it easy. But even as students they leave the judgement and graduation to the ONE and only assessor. The students should only share homework with each other and not be assessing other as the teacher would.
B.T.W- I wasn't implying that you were going off topic, it's just that we all started getting to khalsa definitions. For this issue, there is already another active thread, that's why I mentioned us going off track, as basically we were going in the same direction as another thread.
Waheguru
What I was trying to say was to help eliminate this very issue, which is why I called it the brotherhood and referenced it is a rebirth and new family of equal brothers and sisters.- This way, when one takes amrit, or is baptised, they then become MEMBERS of the khalsa.
Object of all members of this khalsa, the Guru's khalsa, is to become and maintain your TRUE PURITY to the MAXimum level possible.
Like you say, we can refer to them as students if it makes it easy. But even as students they leave the judgement and graduation to the ONE and only assessor. The students should only share homework with each other and not be assessing other as the teacher would.
B.T.W- I wasn't implying that you were going off topic, it's just that we all started getting to khalsa definitions. For this issue, there is already another active thread, that's why I mentioned us going off track, as basically we were going in the same direction as another thread.
Waheguru