vijaydeep Singh
SPNer
Gurfateh Parwan Ho !
Das is only writing about a view of Sirdar Sahib Gurbax singh Ji Kala Afghana Sahib article in english and that also part 2 from spokesmen magzine july 1999.
Das realy respect Sirdar Sahib and if Talwara has made him a sort of 'outcaste' then Talwara has done a big wrong to Panth.As per Das he is gem of a man.
Yet being a former Hindu and still being with the Sangh Parivar Das perhaps knows hinduism better then Sirdar Sahib.And thats what das is going to prove that there could have been interpetation of whole Dasham Guru Darbar,which would have been liked by so called Missionarries(This word is wrong for them better is to use reformers).
So preachers are those who bring non Sikh to Sikhism like Nirmalas,Nihungs Sewa Panthis,Nanaksar,Rara Sahib,Akhand Kirtani Jatha or like sikhmissionary collage etc. So they are real missionaries.Das knows that missoneris in south Asia or in east Africa or in Indian towens are more reformers trying to a sort of 'purifying' or detoxifying Sikhism from pagan rituals,It is a good work.
But they are a more definsive.There record shows say in burma till this day not a single neo convert.But if we say In organisation mentioned above or in Jogi Bhajan or Baba Virsa Singh Ji there are many neo converts.A person can convert a person from another faith only if he /she is aware of his own idealogy.
So far when Das has interacted with missioaries,Das has found out them talking more like christians then Sikhs.They talk of free will of man geven by God.Another old respected person Haqeem T{censored}em Singh Ji was even unable to describe the God of Sikhs yet he a sort of humiliated Das for his faith in Dasham Granth and called him still a hindu.Das gave his point ,he said that he want to meet Das but Das will not be allowed to speak and he will explain.Das so far could not meet him due to some reasons.
But there are many people who after meeting das have understood his point of view.Das is trying to make it public.Only if Akal or Gurubar Akal bless if a single person could understand it Das will feel that Akal has mercy on him.
Das may not be able to complete it today but will try to finish the whole matter as soon as possible.
first of All das is giving a poem written by him and seek the help of any meber of forum to decode it.Perhaps Das knows what he has written and other may try.It is in hindi but letters are in romen.
Neech Bihari
Lehu Ubari
Syam Kandhari
Chhabi Tumari
Bach Uchari
Dhram Hamari
Ichchhit Sanghari
Naam Katari
Oorja Sari
Jitb Pyari
Das will wait for a few days if some one can understand that what das meant. Das wrote it as many writing of Vachitra Natak had some stornger message written in them.A policemen(A Sahib Gurbax Singh Ji was an inspector) may do Danda Pani or Kambal parade to commen civilians but with spies or soldiers it may not happen.
Sleuth or police man is one who protects status que,doubts each and every move and is a bit more defincive and aggresive in approach.This more ture in India.He is a detective.
Spies or soldiers(Das did have training in one of that) are aware of all acts of policemen but they are often more aggresive,they are good in decoding and always try to enter the opponent area and carry out there operation.
Tenth Guru was saint and soldeir equally.Das does not want to enter into slander campaign loucned by a few idiots towards Kala Afghana Sahib but here he wants to tell that after the 'descovery' of Bhag Singh Ji Ambala only did Nirankaris made derogaotry remarks towards Guru that he lived in forest and non is his writing.In Fact Nirnakris are outshoot of reformers only.
But Amabala Sahib did came Back after undoing Tankha.Dasham Granth remained where it was to remain.Das will try that respected Gurbax Singh Ji also undserstand the words of a person who knows more then policemen and can understand by mercy of Akal what Guru Ji wanted to convey.
First Das will give there references he has drawn from Gurmat.
1. In all universe there is nothing else but God.So all forms are made up of God and nothing else but God.
2. God does everything and can do every thing.
3. Salvation can not be obtained by everyone by his/her own deeds but by mercy of Akal.So by mercy of Akal suurender to Akal is to be realised
And concept of dualism/Dwait bhav or Dutiya Bhav or what is more called Duja Bhav in Gurbani.(Das is avoiding giving numbers of Ang as for Das Gurbani is something to be brought in life then a matter of study.Anyone caN read Adi Guru Darbar and get the term Duja Bhav from it).
So as per Duja bhav,That talks of any thing second or other to God.So the root of pain and suffering is this Dujs Bhav.If whole universe is seen as form of God then self ego will be not there and neither there will be others to be afraid of or to be made envious so at that stage by mercy of Akal person gets salvation while alive.
For Das this is the main message of Gurbani.And keeping that in mind das will give those translation or explantion which will be if Akal permits acceptable to Gurbax Singh Ji.
As Das write further lets ask someone in world to give a b c d e from v w x y z.Das thinks it is not possible.So can Gurbax Singh Ji Kala Afghana Ji give OSI model of network from Adi Guru Darbar or TCP/IP model instead.There can be explanation even based on it from Adi Guru Darbar the way it can realy tell us how the automobile runs.But it may not be word to word same.
As he had asked to give at least five verses from Adi Guru Darbar to Justify some parts of Dasham Guru Darbar. The way in 7 there could be 7 1s or 3 2s but in 1 or 2 no seven so as per fact that Dasham Guru Darbar is after Adi Guru Darbar so it will have something more.
It was irony that when Arya Samajis made wrong interpatations of Adi Guru Darbar and coward Bhasuria agreed that Bhagat Bani is not the part of it.A former hindu Prof Sahib Singh Ji did a an explantion better then even Nirmalas of Fareedkot.But when hindutva idiots did same with Dasham Guru Darbar,All enlightened souls joined to Bash it. No one ever tryed to give an unbiased look.
There are some portion of Adi Guru Darbar also like Ramkali Saddu or say something in Verses by First master regarding Jains(Sir Ghitte Saitanis),Had some one not aware of Gurubani can easly take it as if it from 'Brahmin' as Vachitar Natak is taken for.
It is strange Adi Guru Darbar may have been used or Japu Sahib or Akal Ustat to prove that Guru Did not mean that point but points meant some thing else.Same things are even repeated in Vachitar Natak.Das will highlight it.Das is not offending any elder as das is like a worm in front of them but is trying to give a bit more of meaning of Vachitar Nataks wrong explantions as he read in that Magzine.
There is many stuff in Punjabi in his email box but Punjabi of das is weak and so did he got english hard copy version so he did work on it.
So it was Hindutva fools who,did wrong interpetations,Our schoolers surrendered to them and disowned the Granth al toaghter. They were happy as they did do a harm to Panth.There were some agents of them in us who further fueled the fire by saying Sikhs are from generation of Luv Kush.
Perhaps Das is not from that generation.Das father is hindu Vaishya and lowest of all teli.Mother is Hindu Khatri ,who is to do with Pandavas but not Luv Kush,being a product of Pratiloom Vihvah as per hinduism Das is lower to Sudra in Pancham Varna.
So there are two type of people who support Dasham Granth but can not oppose Kala Afghana Ji,One are traiters who work to let us be absorbed in swamp,which Das left to be Sikh.That is hindutva peoiple.In fact They even made 3 Makara of Tantric Vamarg to 5 just to prove that it is like 5ks.And may be they were helped by theory of Kala Afghana Ji to prove Mahakal of Vachitra Natak as Tantik God of Vammarg,the way Ambala Sahib helped nirankaris.
Second type of person are those who are aware that Gurbax Singh Ji is on the wrong side.They have many other important works like to bring mankind to Khalsa fold.They are more busy with that work then to counter his idealogy as they are aware that one or the other day by mercy of Akal,when he reaches the state of Brahm Gyan he will understand what is there in Dasham Guru Darbar.
here das will only give a trailer of how definsive his mentality is,like the one of those Singhs,whom as per Panth Parkash were offered kingdom of foregn land but they prefered to stay in Punjab and make it there state.But know Sikhi has crossed the fronteries of Punjab and new races are coming to its fold.Das is bihari not Punjabi.So when on offensive there is no need to defend.
Cowrads are those hindutva or Arya Samajis who made standrad of Vedas,then based on them wrote a recent version of Manu Samriti.And there to there somethings which were saying something else yet they meant otherwise and removed some verse calling them interpolated.
Who gave authority to police man to make a standard of Adi Guru Darbar to test other Granth.And is his standardisation of idealoguy perfect? Thats the moot question.
More use of logic and no of devotion is mark of Vedanta and not of Gurumat.so those who do this with books are Vedantics and not Gurmukh.Someone said that since Dr. Jodh Singh new Vedas so he did not understand Gurmat and his version of translation is not OK.
Very God,Arya Samajis also said that Gurus did not knew Vedas and his comments apperantly anti to Vedas are due to his obliviance towads VEDAs.
So is it a rule that a person who knows Veda can never be A Sikh or such person is unfit to be Sikh and did Gurus or Bhagats ,who commented on Vedas were unaware of it as they were indeed aware of Gurmat.
Das wants to say that after understanding Gurbani real crux of Veda is understood.
to be continued....
Das is only writing about a view of Sirdar Sahib Gurbax singh Ji Kala Afghana Sahib article in english and that also part 2 from spokesmen magzine july 1999.
Das realy respect Sirdar Sahib and if Talwara has made him a sort of 'outcaste' then Talwara has done a big wrong to Panth.As per Das he is gem of a man.
Yet being a former Hindu and still being with the Sangh Parivar Das perhaps knows hinduism better then Sirdar Sahib.And thats what das is going to prove that there could have been interpetation of whole Dasham Guru Darbar,which would have been liked by so called Missionarries(This word is wrong for them better is to use reformers).
So preachers are those who bring non Sikh to Sikhism like Nirmalas,Nihungs Sewa Panthis,Nanaksar,Rara Sahib,Akhand Kirtani Jatha or like sikhmissionary collage etc. So they are real missionaries.Das knows that missoneris in south Asia or in east Africa or in Indian towens are more reformers trying to a sort of 'purifying' or detoxifying Sikhism from pagan rituals,It is a good work.
But they are a more definsive.There record shows say in burma till this day not a single neo convert.But if we say In organisation mentioned above or in Jogi Bhajan or Baba Virsa Singh Ji there are many neo converts.A person can convert a person from another faith only if he /she is aware of his own idealogy.
So far when Das has interacted with missioaries,Das has found out them talking more like christians then Sikhs.They talk of free will of man geven by God.Another old respected person Haqeem T{censored}em Singh Ji was even unable to describe the God of Sikhs yet he a sort of humiliated Das for his faith in Dasham Granth and called him still a hindu.Das gave his point ,he said that he want to meet Das but Das will not be allowed to speak and he will explain.Das so far could not meet him due to some reasons.
But there are many people who after meeting das have understood his point of view.Das is trying to make it public.Only if Akal or Gurubar Akal bless if a single person could understand it Das will feel that Akal has mercy on him.
Das may not be able to complete it today but will try to finish the whole matter as soon as possible.
first of All das is giving a poem written by him and seek the help of any meber of forum to decode it.Perhaps Das knows what he has written and other may try.It is in hindi but letters are in romen.
Neech Bihari
Lehu Ubari
Syam Kandhari
Chhabi Tumari
Bach Uchari
Dhram Hamari
Ichchhit Sanghari
Naam Katari
Oorja Sari
Jitb Pyari
Das will wait for a few days if some one can understand that what das meant. Das wrote it as many writing of Vachitra Natak had some stornger message written in them.A policemen(A Sahib Gurbax Singh Ji was an inspector) may do Danda Pani or Kambal parade to commen civilians but with spies or soldiers it may not happen.
Sleuth or police man is one who protects status que,doubts each and every move and is a bit more defincive and aggresive in approach.This more ture in India.He is a detective.
Spies or soldiers(Das did have training in one of that) are aware of all acts of policemen but they are often more aggresive,they are good in decoding and always try to enter the opponent area and carry out there operation.
Tenth Guru was saint and soldeir equally.Das does not want to enter into slander campaign loucned by a few idiots towards Kala Afghana Sahib but here he wants to tell that after the 'descovery' of Bhag Singh Ji Ambala only did Nirankaris made derogaotry remarks towards Guru that he lived in forest and non is his writing.In Fact Nirnakris are outshoot of reformers only.
But Amabala Sahib did came Back after undoing Tankha.Dasham Granth remained where it was to remain.Das will try that respected Gurbax Singh Ji also undserstand the words of a person who knows more then policemen and can understand by mercy of Akal what Guru Ji wanted to convey.
First Das will give there references he has drawn from Gurmat.
1. In all universe there is nothing else but God.So all forms are made up of God and nothing else but God.
2. God does everything and can do every thing.
3. Salvation can not be obtained by everyone by his/her own deeds but by mercy of Akal.So by mercy of Akal suurender to Akal is to be realised
And concept of dualism/Dwait bhav or Dutiya Bhav or what is more called Duja Bhav in Gurbani.(Das is avoiding giving numbers of Ang as for Das Gurbani is something to be brought in life then a matter of study.Anyone caN read Adi Guru Darbar and get the term Duja Bhav from it).
So as per Duja bhav,That talks of any thing second or other to God.So the root of pain and suffering is this Dujs Bhav.If whole universe is seen as form of God then self ego will be not there and neither there will be others to be afraid of or to be made envious so at that stage by mercy of Akal person gets salvation while alive.
For Das this is the main message of Gurbani.And keeping that in mind das will give those translation or explantion which will be if Akal permits acceptable to Gurbax Singh Ji.
As Das write further lets ask someone in world to give a b c d e from v w x y z.Das thinks it is not possible.So can Gurbax Singh Ji Kala Afghana Ji give OSI model of network from Adi Guru Darbar or TCP/IP model instead.There can be explanation even based on it from Adi Guru Darbar the way it can realy tell us how the automobile runs.But it may not be word to word same.
As he had asked to give at least five verses from Adi Guru Darbar to Justify some parts of Dasham Guru Darbar. The way in 7 there could be 7 1s or 3 2s but in 1 or 2 no seven so as per fact that Dasham Guru Darbar is after Adi Guru Darbar so it will have something more.
It was irony that when Arya Samajis made wrong interpatations of Adi Guru Darbar and coward Bhasuria agreed that Bhagat Bani is not the part of it.A former hindu Prof Sahib Singh Ji did a an explantion better then even Nirmalas of Fareedkot.But when hindutva idiots did same with Dasham Guru Darbar,All enlightened souls joined to Bash it. No one ever tryed to give an unbiased look.
There are some portion of Adi Guru Darbar also like Ramkali Saddu or say something in Verses by First master regarding Jains(Sir Ghitte Saitanis),Had some one not aware of Gurubani can easly take it as if it from 'Brahmin' as Vachitar Natak is taken for.
It is strange Adi Guru Darbar may have been used or Japu Sahib or Akal Ustat to prove that Guru Did not mean that point but points meant some thing else.Same things are even repeated in Vachitar Natak.Das will highlight it.Das is not offending any elder as das is like a worm in front of them but is trying to give a bit more of meaning of Vachitar Nataks wrong explantions as he read in that Magzine.
There is many stuff in Punjabi in his email box but Punjabi of das is weak and so did he got english hard copy version so he did work on it.
So it was Hindutva fools who,did wrong interpetations,Our schoolers surrendered to them and disowned the Granth al toaghter. They were happy as they did do a harm to Panth.There were some agents of them in us who further fueled the fire by saying Sikhs are from generation of Luv Kush.
Perhaps Das is not from that generation.Das father is hindu Vaishya and lowest of all teli.Mother is Hindu Khatri ,who is to do with Pandavas but not Luv Kush,being a product of Pratiloom Vihvah as per hinduism Das is lower to Sudra in Pancham Varna.
So there are two type of people who support Dasham Granth but can not oppose Kala Afghana Ji,One are traiters who work to let us be absorbed in swamp,which Das left to be Sikh.That is hindutva peoiple.In fact They even made 3 Makara of Tantric Vamarg to 5 just to prove that it is like 5ks.And may be they were helped by theory of Kala Afghana Ji to prove Mahakal of Vachitra Natak as Tantik God of Vammarg,the way Ambala Sahib helped nirankaris.
Second type of person are those who are aware that Gurbax Singh Ji is on the wrong side.They have many other important works like to bring mankind to Khalsa fold.They are more busy with that work then to counter his idealogy as they are aware that one or the other day by mercy of Akal,when he reaches the state of Brahm Gyan he will understand what is there in Dasham Guru Darbar.
here das will only give a trailer of how definsive his mentality is,like the one of those Singhs,whom as per Panth Parkash were offered kingdom of foregn land but they prefered to stay in Punjab and make it there state.But know Sikhi has crossed the fronteries of Punjab and new races are coming to its fold.Das is bihari not Punjabi.So when on offensive there is no need to defend.
Cowrads are those hindutva or Arya Samajis who made standrad of Vedas,then based on them wrote a recent version of Manu Samriti.And there to there somethings which were saying something else yet they meant otherwise and removed some verse calling them interpolated.
Who gave authority to police man to make a standard of Adi Guru Darbar to test other Granth.And is his standardisation of idealoguy perfect? Thats the moot question.
More use of logic and no of devotion is mark of Vedanta and not of Gurumat.so those who do this with books are Vedantics and not Gurmukh.Someone said that since Dr. Jodh Singh new Vedas so he did not understand Gurmat and his version of translation is not OK.
Very God,Arya Samajis also said that Gurus did not knew Vedas and his comments apperantly anti to Vedas are due to his obliviance towads VEDAs.
So is it a rule that a person who knows Veda can never be A Sikh or such person is unfit to be Sikh and did Gurus or Bhagats ,who commented on Vedas were unaware of it as they were indeed aware of Gurmat.
Das wants to say that after understanding Gurbani real crux of Veda is understood.
to be continued....