• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Dasam Granth - A Critical Study

Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

Das is soory that he could not continue on it in past and will be giving a bit more things today.

Anand Sahib say that world/universe is sleeping in three quality and it is correct that universe has three matteriallistcs qualities but they are also nothing as God is in them.The world which you see is from of God the same Anand Sahib say.

So in Vachitar Natak Akal is called one in Page 54 as some where Rajsa Tamas Satkeyan ie some where practicle/matterialistic,Somewhere Evil and somewhere good it is all Akal.

Then in time in the same page that(God) Past,Future,Present happens so it is God who occur in three times and no one else(Das will explain 3 Makari Tantric phelosophy someday and how does it differ from unpresedented Gurmat).

Then in page 61 see it is said that in 14 worlds(it is a symbol of whole universe) has light extended.

The one light who is in all(Arti Sahib of Guru Granth Sahib Ji).It may be taken as if some one has extenede light in whole unverse and that is coorect as that light only or that energy only made universe.

So this proves that By Dasham Dranths Vachitar Natak Akal is everywhere in Bad and in God and in practicle and in the one who is beyond them.

Then two more things one is 57 and 58 pages
58 page has line and further explantion that in universe all living beings who are on land or water(that is for all space as a symbol) ,who is there who could disobey your comamnd(Huqam of Akal or will of God is undisobeyable) no one can give answere to this question as answere may have negative reply as all are under will of God.So this types of questions are just to negate something and here the existance of any thing which could go against the will of God.


also it is said that(at) all place,Continously,Eternally,New (that is attribute of God in Vachitar Natak)

page 57 says

Sabe lok Bhop or King of universe


then furhter ahead in the same context
that one from start to end but kept forms un countable(unlimited).

then page 53 says Kalan Karanaya

or reason of movemeant(s) ie all deeds in universe are done by Akal's will.

In 58 again it is said that moves cycle of cycles in fourteen worlds(whole universe) rotates,Increseing, decresing,nourshing,fullfilling.

Das wants to prove by these quotes that all actions are done by Akal as per Vachitar Natak also.

So if we say that Bedi Bhaye Prasan Raj Ko Paye Ke
Det Bhayo Vardan Hiye Hulsai Ke

then it could be understood that Bedi were happy after getting kingdom.

and Blessing(Vardan/Asheesh/Prasad das will expalin all later) was given by one(as Bedis were Bhaye or many became happy but Blessing was made by one Bhayo or Det Bhayo) after making the heart happy.

The one who did happines(Hullas which made Hullsai) to the Hearts(Hiyee this could be singular and plural but here as Many Bedis were there so Thier Hearts are plural).

It could be understood that Bedis were made happy by Gopd only and that God only did gvae a blessing to Sodis also after making hearts of Bedis happy.

This could be one of the mesaning and other could be that one opf the Bedi only gave blessing but in any case all acts are by God.As god is in all.

Then we have Bardan terms used which Sirdar Sahib ji are taking for boom.Das will explain it soon.
(to Be continued....)
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

Well now Das will ponder on term Bardaan taken as boom by Sirdar Sahib.

Yes upto certion extent it is true that some idiotic sants of us and mnay Brahmanical fools misguide innnocnet masses by saying that they can provided boom.

But say in this case it is still not clear that Bedi only did gave boom.As either one of the Bedi gave it or perhaps it may also mean some one other then those plural(Bedis) gave Vardan.

Det Bhyo Bardan cann not mean Det(giver) became Boom.It is absurd but may not be ruled out.

In Japu Sahib,Term Ajaat or non born is used.It is attribute or Adjective and hence name for Akal made by verb.

So Jaan Ko Det Ajan Ko Det,Jammen Ko Det Jamaan Ko Dey Hai(Akalustat) this part is considered to be by Tenth Master by those who say Dasham Granth is interpolated butDas can say that may be Japu Sahib could be interpolATED if one could be then other could be.

Say if Raag Mala is interpolated And even in say page number of 972 or 792 of Kartar Puri Copy which was adjudged by Bhai Jodh Singh(not the Dr Jodh Singh) as first copy.And in same hand writing and same ink Raagmala is there with all other Gurbani(Santookh Singh is also right saying that it is not created by Guru as like Bani of Kabir it could have been taken from other source).Second copy of Bhai Bannu still there in Kanpur has it.Then Copy having Guruship or Damdami version oldest of that also has it.

Main problem here is that unlike Christians who do no propogate old testment but some time even more then four gospel of new testment they more propogate act of apostales.

In our Case instead of relying more(at each step) on Bani of Brahmans like Surdas or Jaidev Ji(this Bhagat was even before Gurus time) in Guru Granth Sahib Ji if we come and see a bit of creatons our own Sikhs also.Das can say that Gurbani of Guru Granth Sahib Ji has verse to be used eternally but in some situations in past Sikh soliders may have had taken some steps which Bhagat Jai Dev Ji,Sheik Farid Ji,Sant Kabir Ji or Bhagat Surdas Ji may never have done.

In the same light instaed of denying it we can accept that that was a compulsion of time.Gurbani is timeless and from timeless.Das is sorry to use a bit harsh words.

Then coming Back to det word in Akalustat it may mean giver and may also mean giving and may also means gives(always).That could be an adjectve there fore and all name of Akal are adjective or attributes.

Yet Akal became boom or Det Bhyo Vardan may not be coorect but Vardaan from Akal suits what we call Gurmats ideology.

Other name for giving some one are
Asis or Blessing.

Puta Mata Ki Asis is from Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

But Asis is made up of two words

Asa Ish or Hope(asa) Wanting(ish).So it is blessing that some one gives other like i want (ish or Ist or Ichchha) may(hope) Akal bless you.In the case of Asis or Asirwad it may happen and may not happen but there is a hope by elder person.

In Case of Vardan
Va(with) Ra(stay) Dan(donation) it is done that it will be with the reciver given by doner.

Well in our Mool Mantra there is term which is same as Vardan.

It is Prasad(it was in fact the surname of Das before becoming Singh).
Pra(higher(being)) Sa(that(either object given or doner)) D(give).

so Prasad is also some one high gives to a lowere person.And Guru Prasad or SatigurPrasad all say that all giver is Akal and all takers are us.

When it comes to boom.Well in that case of bardaan some person does a sort of Tapasya or physicallly demamnding worship to get back some reward from deity.

Many demons like Hirnkshyap,Ravan,Mahishasur etc. in old storys did this.

But did Sodi King did such thing to get back something?

No,He only did Dharam(or good work) by restoring back the rights of one(Bedis) who were doiong good deeds.

And God was happy to see this effort of sacrifise without asking anything in return by sodi and so blessing or Prasad or Vardan was given by Akal.

*Gurbani says one who does Service without any desire gets Lord.

But in this case this sodi only tried to a sort of undoing of wrong and took intiative which lead his family to be blessed(This could be only one of the possibility but when we see history of that time then words from * till here do not seem to be coorect but can be researched)

There is something related to that time which made Guru to say this story which Das will explain later.
(to Be continued....)
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

So As such Das moves further.

Here Sirdar Sahib made a few more point which Das think were a bit absurd.

Das want to say that in Gurbani it is said that Brahman was made by akal to say Veda but he himslef could not become perfect.

There could be very deep meaning in it.

We have St. Kabir,Surdas Ji And Shiek Farid Ji among many other Bhagats in Contributing to Gurubani.

But many of thier verse were not put in there.Nor life followed by all of them is told to us to follow like we are not told to worship Krishna like surdas or sit in front of stonne Like Dhanna Ji or Worship Mecca like Sheikh Farid Ji.

But they also got at one point of time Holy Verses from Akal. So they like Brahma did gave good and worthy verse but that those not mean that we should worship them or follow them instead of becomg Khalsa which came much after them and as a foll proof Faith.

Das wrote that as in one Farsi Verse Akal is termed as Haqa Kabir Kareem Tu,BiEEB Parwar Degaar.

Foolish Gharib Dasis(Branch of Kabirists or Kabir Panthis who hypothaically are going against tenants of St Kabir) ,who beg from Gurudwaras to eat(Sant Kabeer never did this but woked to earn by making cloths) say that that verse of Gurubani tells Sikh that God is Kabir so Sikh must worship him.

But Sau Sakhi says that Kabir and mata Loi had to tek rebirth as a Sikh of Tenth master to get Salvation.So Khalsa is more then sufficinet to counter the physcological warfare some time done by Kabir Panthis and at present done by Hindutva.

Well hindutva try to remind us our race of Hinduism older them Panth.If Panthis obsolate then why should not that race be obsolate.If something Sikhs can see before them then it is Islam.To be more in chain.Vedic and Pre VEdic Aryan(Civilised) People were Sikhs as they worship Akal.They were foreced to cut thier hairs and worship persons or Idols by Budhist nanda king(Sau Sakhi) some of them left India into another Country.

Race of Jew is the same Brahmin/Aryan Race.From Jews did Chritians emerged from Christians Islam from by adding few more unprecedented things like Salvation for non Beliver and no ritualism and no concept of {censored} did Gurmat came(Vachitar Natak also has sismilar thing regarding the fact that Gurmat is nearest to Islam while Jews and Christian issues are idscuused in Sau Sakhi(Mangal Prakash)).

Hinduism or Hindutva are just 100 or 200 year old things.Das does not want to offend any of Hindu so will not give more detail that hindu was a derogatory remark by pagan Irano Aryans,who were punished by akal as they become refuggess as a parsi in the Land of same Hindus.but present day Iranis who are Shia respect the world Hindu as Faith or Race.

Coming Back to Islam unlike budhism there is no personal worship in there and God worship is there.Hinduism or Brahmanisam could not abosorbed it.By the way even Budhism due to Dr Ambedkar is Back and playing havoc with Brahmanism.

Well to keep Brahmanism at bay we need to do the following.
1. No worship of object or person but Akal as other things can trap us in Brahimanism.
2. No Caste or Race
3. No ritualism is to be tolarted.Das here want to say that we have one penticostal version of Sikh Jatha but Penticostal are not very stron in front of Hindutva either.(note Penticostal church is protestant faith with a lot of miracle attached).

So coming Back to the point

Next line says that

In Kaliyuga when we /I come as Nanak and be reknowned.(i) will be worshipped in Universe and make you attainn high position.

so Far these are the meaning which Sirdar Sahib have understood.

Say he says that as per Vars of Bhai Gurdas Ji only after world said or called them Akal sent Guru Nanak Dev Ji so this goes against the Gurbani as Vaars of Bhai Gurdas are keys to Gurbani.

Das here want to say that as per Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha Ji not all the Vars are keys and there is a doubts on many.

like the one he disaproves
Wa of Wahiguru is from Vasudev in one age(Yuga).Ha is from Hari in another Yuga,Ga for Gobind in anotther Yuga and Ra from Raam in another Yuga.

Well Bhai Sahib disaprroved it,But Das apporves it as for Das Vasudev,Hari ,Gobind and Rama are not the Avtars(incarnations) but attribute(Siffat) of Akal.In holy Kuran also there are about 99 names of Allah but Allah is one.Vasudev is one who live in all places,Hari is sustainer,Gobind is the one who igves comfert to go(Senses) and Ram is absorbed in universe.

So that particular Var which was absurdly used by Sirdar Sahib out of context is not in out of context with the same verses of Vachitar Natak.

It is God who says that God's Mainfestation as Nanak(here in first person) will come in Kali(evil age).So as per Vachitar Natak only by these lines infereance can be drwan that it was destained by Akal in other Yuga(age) that in evil dark age,A Form of Nanak will come.So as per Var of Bhai Gurdas Ji evil age did come(by will of Akal),People did became unhappy(by will of Akal) and they did make pukar(prayer for mercy to Akal be will of Akal) and Manifestation as Nanak was placed in evil age on earth.(Das is thinking that there could be a great sort of influnece of person worshipping Saguna Bhakti people or Protrestant Christians on the Schollras like Sirdar Sahib so he wanted to made this thing regarding the personality of Guru Sahib or his birth as a big issue).In fact unlike hindus that on celebration of something one this particular day gets Punya(a sort of earning in view of demigods in positive way) we can celebrate GuruParb on any Day.We nned to take inspiration.

That was the reason that Das did support Nanak Shahi Calender and another being making hue and cry by Sangh Parivar to oppose Nanakshahi Calender other wise be it luner or Vikrami or soler or Nanakshahi it is irrelevant for us.Gurus teaching matters and not the birth.

So Das does not find any contradiction.When somneone is saying that in evil age a birth is to happen that means that it has to happen to undo evil.and evil become prominent when large mass of human amke prayer to come out of pain due to evil.So all was predestained which Bhai Sahib Gurdas Ji and Writer of Vachitar Natak as per Das Guru himself wrote.

Das reapeat that in that age only it was predestained that wrong will happen and to undo it Nanak will come. But why should this Guru write who opposees the forcast.

Answer is simple,he has a good lot of demorolised lower castes,hindus,Shias ,Sufies among many others who are both physically and mentalyy tourchered by bigot Rajpoot and Mughal kingdom and both use thier scriputres misinterpetaiuon to prove that Naqshbandi Sunnis and Rajpoots are destained to exploite other.

Then Guru had to reveal that As per Akal,As per Worshipper of Akal.Nanak is a Manifestation of Akal which will put end to nonesesness inhuman things.And this the bright future and destinay and from So Far Ten Bodies soon Nanak will have countless boides in the form of Khalsa and as an idealogy of Verbal Manifestaion of Akal in heart of Guru Panth,will destroy evil.And it did happen.(Das want to say that both Ugrandi Bani regarding Jage Dhram Hindu and Var of Bhai Gurdas second,Hinduk Thahiraye is rather highly anti hindutva or hinduism which das will elaborate furhter)

(To Be continued..)
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

Know Das will rewrite the verses

Jab Nanak Kal mai Hum Aan Kahaiye Hai.Ho Jagat pooj Kar Tohe Param Pad Payye Hai.

These are very open sentance.

When in Evil period,We(here person is single as det Bhyo but speaking as if plural as in India highness speak like that and here this highness could be Akal) will come and be called/renowned as Nanak.Happned(make you) Worshipped in universe ,dooing it and to you give the high status.

Das will write it in clear language which could be its real meaning,After coing in Evil age as Nanak(due to crys of agony of humans due to pain caused by evil).To you(Sodi Family) we will make worshipped in universe and thereafter you will get high position(spritualy it may means salvation).

so far Sirdar Sahib did interpreted it as Bedi said that he will be reborn as Nanak and will make Sodi as Guru and thence Bedi will get salvation.

There is a clear cut influence of personal worship on Sirdar Sahib and perhaps his presdecessors due to influence of Protestants as they also worship the personality of Jesus or perhaps pagan influnece of worship of Rama or Krishana.Who so ever worship personas can make such interpetaions.

While it could be interpreted in another way ie that in Sodis Akal Said that in us Nanak will come in evil Era.And thence in your Family you will get worship form world and thence your family will thereafter get salvation(this not bedis but a blessing to sodis).

Thence it ends as thereafter Luvis went to jungle(had they took sanyasa and did not had made Jungle habitable by making famly life then we may not have got the coming generations of Gurus so this again prove that going to jungle does not means to take Sanyas) and Bedis utilised the kingdom.

As Bedis are know busy with kingdom and sodis are in jungle but narration continues this is another proof that nither Bedi spoke nor Sodies listen in that blessing but some one else was saying it and that was Akal.

Then it is described that Three Vedas You(Sodis who have gone in the Jungle so are not in frotn of Bedis but are still infront of Akal like das is still) Listen.And after listening Fourth one you gave the Land/kingdom.

These lines are describing the good deed of Sodi king who after testing Bedis of thier knowledge and authenticity of his information returned Bedis thier right.Next line no where say that it is due to Reading Fourth Veda did Sodi has been blessed.It is only saying that After listening the whole of Vedas did Kingdom was returned.Then Sirdar Sahib made absurd things in his style of intelectual gymnastic.

He askes had there been only three Vedas what would have happened.Das can ask him that in if Raagmala is not corect them Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji's volume may not be same.Or Had Bani of Ninth Master was not added it would have been differnt and Has some Raga was not not the Part of Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji yet Sirdar Gurbax Singh Ji Kala Afghana still would have remained the Adi Granth Purist.

Das is sorry to bring in Guru Granth Sahib Ji in but Das was compelled by logic used by Sirdar Sahib often used by Arya Samajis.

So weather Vedas were four or more or less.it hardly matters only thing was that after veryfing the full knowlegde of Vedas did king gave the Kingdom.

Then blesser Says that when We(i) take three Births.In Fourth birth of blesser self,Guruship wiill be in your family.

Thing to rember that blesser is going to take three birth and Fouth will be of blesser but will be in the Family of Sodi king.It may be within the linage of King. Or may not be within the linage of king but in any other Sodi ,who was with King.but Das think more to do with Kings own linage(this measn that king did do rehabitation in jungle unlike asetic Nath Yogis).

Thing to rember again is that Three preivous Birth are not Bedi only.One is Bedi,another Tehan(Jatt) or Trehan(Khatri) and Bhalla.It also proves that Bedi is not the speaker but another speaker is there who is thinking or speaking but Bedis or Sodis do not know this.And no where Bedis gave first three Gurus.And fourth birth is also of the same speaker but in sodi family.

(To Be continued)
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

Sirdar Sahib then said that as till fourth is writtan so as till fourth Birth boom is writtan then this will mean that as per Vachitar Natak only Guruship can go till four Guru.

Well When Das says that he will go to Toroanto then this may not mean that Das will not go to Vancuver.Das is using the names of cities of his nation.So till Fourth if something is writtan then this does not mean that further we are not going to have Guru.

In fact Guru Gur Eko Ves Aneek.One Guru but difernt forms of Akal.Since First Master till know in the form of Five Beloved one or In Guru Panth(Faith itslef is Guru in communtiy).

Then four Birth can be like that First Master by Birth.Second Master after conversion to Sikhism.Same to Third and Fourth Guru.Thing to rember here is that all till Fourth(Das can say that only after the episode of Vein Reiver First Master could be Guru as Das considered Sikhism as Revealed Religeon and Semitic faith in line of Judaisim,Christianity and Islam) were at one time non Sikh and thier Birth was thier conversion to Sikhism.Gurubanis says that Nanak Naam Mele Tan Jeevan Tan Man Theve Harya. Oh Nanak(As per Das whole Gurubani is not the poems by holy men as claimed by some hindutva misguided brothers,It is sermons/Verses sent on Holy personas by Akal,our eternal God)

So Oh Nanak by getting the name of (Akal) I will be Reived/Born and mind and body will be norurished.By Name Birth does occur spritualy and that could be real birht of human other birth by mother womb does happen to animals also.

Then Next thing with in the name Bachitar Natak further ahehad name of All Gurus till Ninth are Givne and needless to say that it is again wriitan on pages 72 and 73 that there were no Differanance between any Gurus onece they were Gurus.Das also want to say that only initial Four or Three Gurus can at one time could be said that were Tehan,Bhalla or Sodi Caste as they were not Sikh,Once they became Sikh then they were Sikh onlky so reamining Six Gurus were no longer sodisa.

AS PER Vars of bhai Gurudas Ji Sikh became Guru and Guru Became Sikh(This is Bhai Gurdas first and not the second) So attainin Sikhhood was at that time was also attaining Guruhood or Panth Guru was then also present ie even before Khalsa.And Fifth to Tenth Guru had Sikh parents so at any time they were not non Sikh so Conversion or Spritual Janam or Birth may not be recorded.

Then it is writtan that That Particular King went to forest.And here these(Again plural) Bedis had utisled the Kingdom and got pleasure and pleasue in ruling means to serve as per Gurmat and we can deem here the same instead of thinking like hindu.And then that all was relvent as writer says.

Then again one more important thing happens.Writer who as per Das is Guru write a good thing. Again querel was risen.Was not controled by nayone.Deed of (A)kal heppened as such that all land was taken away from them.

So only by Akal does family or gruop fights and all Wealth goes away from Hand.These things make us understand what Guru wanted to convey and it was more relevent at the time of Prof Gurumukh Singh Ji when he was oppsoing the same Vachitar Natak without understanding that the same would have helped him.

Das want to say all this story Guru made just to illustrate that by Deeds of one holy man by mercy of Akal,We must not start to worship whole the faimly be it Sodi or Be it Bedi.They were and there could be wrong in them.

Das can list like Masands,Minas,Dhirmailas,Ramrayas. who were claiming to be holy due to blood link with Gurus and even some Udasis were not up to the mark.So Crux here was to let people understand by story to not to follow the family but good person by good dded by mercy of Akal.

And as by that time Guruship was to be givme to the Panth. And at that time by stoys and that of old time Gurus were able to put forwards thier views very correctly had they used pictures or idols then it would not have been good for Panth.Lord Jesus and other holy prophets might have used the same way.

In Fact in Guru Granth Sahib Ji also
We have Rama,Ravana,Dhru,Prahlad,Yamraj,Garurh and countless names which may not be true at poresent but can be used for illustration but here to end Families attempt to high jack did Guru used the Family stroy.

(to be continued)
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh


Well Das here want to tender an apology to all if Das has used word hindu as a derogaotry but it is ture that many of our own Sikhs are mere turbanned Hindus and are unable to understand the deep rooted mesasge in Gurmat and Gurbani especcialy the one in Dasham Granth.

Das anyway does not hate Hindus but want that all Hindus as Das deem that it is same as Indian(RSS also belives the same) Must give up thier nationality called Hinduism and take the universal nationality unbounded call Sikhi(sm).

And any Sikh who wants to say that Sikhi is something to do with punjabi cultrue then there is no differance between him and any Hindutva person.

Das did use the term to say that Guramt is more Revleaed faith inspite of the fact that many present day Nirmalas do not belive in it.

Reason is that our Faiht has tlak of our Gurus or Holy men with God.It is there in holy Bible or Holy Kuran but in no scripture revered by Hindus.Yes there are instance of talks with demi gods or Deities but not with fromless Akal.

But both in vein River episode and in Vachitar Natak we have talk of Guru with God.In Japu Ji Sahib there is a line Nanak Gaya Jape Jayi.It may means that Akl is telling Guru that oh Nanak in that realme,Gone appears to have gone.This is the theory of realtivity.Ie What appears to have been destroyed or Gone is only apperant but Thruth is that form has cahnged.Suraj Kiran Mili Jal Ka Jal Hoava Ram,Jyoti Jyot Ralee....

Ray meets Sun,Water goes Back to water,Light meets Light and completeness is obtained.But in the line of gone appears to have gone another meaning could be It appears to Nanak of being gone there.If second one is ture then it is ture that Guru did go in front of Akal.

And di bring the message that no one is Hindu nor anyone is Muslim as God by self is free from religeous boundaries.

Coming Back to main text.

There King Reached(Sidhyoo) Jungle(Kanan).Here they (Bedis) did rule and got pleasure.

Then other irrerelavnat things Guru did not wrote.

Then again for them it is writtan that there wasthere weree internal tussle and land was lost(Das wants to remind Panth that to be united or the same may happen with us as it happended during Anglo Sikh War,Internal strife causes looss and thats the message here).

Then time came when Holy men started to act as low.Brahims acted like sudras.Politicians or Kshtriyas started to act like traders ie rulers became more mony minded and wanted to exploit ruled.

Capitliast or Trader or Vaishyas acted like rulers or by mony power started to make state run expoliting have nots.

And loweres of Sudras of that time realy did work of twice born one by birth and another by sprituality.

Here writer is talking about St Kabir,Namdev,Sadhana,Ravi Das Ji among others whose verses are in Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Bedis were left with ten villages and were doping agricultrue there.For long they lived like that.Then time of birth of Nanak Came.

Then for first time it is writtan that in the family of those Bedis did King Nanak appeared.Gave benefit ot all Sikhs and Here and there were help full(in all conditions).

He in this evil era made rightoussness to move(kal main Dharma Chalyo)And Adi Guru Granth Sahib also say Nanak Nirmal(without impurity) Panth(way) Chalya(Made ot move).

Told all good people way.

Who so ever came to his way.that was delvered from pain by sins.
who so ever went to his way.sins and sorrow of that were removed by Lord.
Sorrow and hunger(Greed) does never make unhappy(Sataye).
Never came into the trap(cycle) of time/Death.

so will there be any ideot Demonsied so called Brahmin as told by Sirdar Sahib telling all that.Then all the labour he did to absoreb Sikhs into Hinduism,Will he put in drain by saying that Guru Nanak's Marg writtan in Guru Granth Sahib Ji is coorect and to be followed.

Well as Brahimn as per Sirdar Sahib Ji are cunning then why will a Brahimn do anything which makes other eager to read Guru Granth Sahib Ji so that Anti Caste and Anti Brahmnicalism things be got from there and people like Sirdar Sahib will adjudged that writer is wrong.

No one will what we say in hindu blow the axe on his own feet.And no one as per ploicy of Brahimns leave anything on chance by like leaving a whole in a boat.so that let is sink.There is no contradiction with two books but rather something called lack of complete knwoledge of many other factors other then idealogy which are miking someone think wrong and again the same is preached to others innocent people.

Both RSS and Sirdar Sahib are infact not knowing the text correctly and relaying upon translation rather then understadning the origeonal by themselves.And why do the avood Hard work God only knows.

Next lines to be more precise
Nanak took birth as Angad(rember this thing that Name Angad was Gievn to lehana Ji on Guruship being given and thence there was no diffreance between Nanak and Angad(like the limb of Nanak).He preached Dhrama(Rithousness ) in this universe.Again name was called Amerdas.Like from one Lamp another Lamp was enlightened.

at the time of blessing came.Ramdas was called Guru.
Next line is important.
He gave the old Blessing and took the way of Heavan(Akal).

Here Third Master is not at all Bedi but one with Akal as Guru Nanak so it is another proof that giver of blessing was Akal.

Sri Nanak deemed Anagad as (his) Hand/Sri Nanak was recoganised as Angad.
Amardas was recogansed as Angad.Amer Das was called Ramdas.Good people saw this(that all four were one),But FOOLs did not find/get this.

all/most deemed as differnt(forms of Nanak).(only few) recoganised that it was only one form.

Those who recogainsed(one form) got proof(Sidhi).Without understanding proof does not come in hand(possesion).

This can be true for Akal also that Akal is in all and those who see Akal in such a way get Sidhi or Proof.Sidhi in Yogis mean the power to prove them selve with suparnatral power but in Sikhs Sidhi is Proof Of Akal.

Das thinks that writer was aware at that time that personas like Sirdar Sahib will raise fingers about differance of caste etc. of Gurus so did writer wrote these lines to let them understand that in All Akal exists.

Das was surprised that any person who gives a good lot of article to prove that Dasham Granth is not as per Guru Granth Sahib they tend to give refreance from both which appear to be diffreant but always ommit the one nearby in the same chapters perhaps which give tolat comfirmity.

Das would like to discuss that often it is said that it is Chankya's policy that Brahimn first try to act as sympthiser and later ditches.Das wants to say here that it is a hoax and Das did read Chankya Niti in Child hood and book Artha Shastra but this thing may not be exclusivly with Brahimns but many non Hindus also have used it.and often there are examples that many time like Maulana Suhbhatt of Kashmeer Brahmins rather became tourchbeaer of Faith(Islam in this case) to destroy Brahminism.

We have such people with our history since Bhai Alam Singh to Prof Sahib Singh Ji to Akali Kaur Singh ji,all had hindu Brahmins Ancestor from fathers side but after coing to Panth they become with All Caste,Family of Guru ie Khalsa.

Perhaps equalting Khalsa with Budhism or Jainism who are non belivers of God we have had so lower sprit that we loose confidance in omnipotant Akal and be afraid of fictatious Brahimin.

By the way is our Gurmat so weak that anyperson who is writing so deep things of spritua;ity will still like to continue with all hypocratic faith while writeing something to adultrate it.

Gurmat is like fire and anyone who comes with the water of adultration rahter get that water dreid and himself becoming fuel to that fire.

(to be continued...)
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

Before Das starts Das would like to give a bit of interpetation of Ugrandi Bani which is edited in sgpc or Taksali version of Dasham Granth ie it may not be in the one compled by bhai Mani Singh Ji and Baba Virsa Singh Ji may not support it.

It is lie that that writer ask the light formed God blessing to exaust the fantic Turks.And to elimnate the killing of go.So here Hindus jumped that it is taliked about cow as they thought that go is cow in Sanskrit.

It shows that Sikhs know Sanskrit better then Brahmins and at another forum one Nirmala gave prroof of one of thier farmer Pandit defeating Brahmans.

Well In Sanskri Gaubha is the the same for cow and Gau is also used.While term Gobind,Goswami etc is has deepr meaning.

Go is Indri or senses. Killing of Go or sense is something to do with what we daily rember Dekh Ke Andhitth Karan.Inspite of seeing does not see.

Like young sons could be butchered in front of eyes but did not give faith and did not 'see' it or acted as does not seen it.

Killing of sense also means to be senseless killer and that was to be eliminated by writer.

Then it is said that in whole world does the way of Khalsa shall roar.As a result of that further two races are menatuioned.

Dhrama(Rithousness) of Hindus will Awake(as it was sleeping till then and by Bani of Khalsa they will awake as Sikh) and Mist(of bigotry) of turk will run away.

Hindutva people misinterpreted it by saying that sole purpose of faith is to let hindus awake and dreive away turks which a Hindu idolator can think but servent of Akal does not.

Das just repeat this thing,

Suraj was not sun but a good person as told in Vachitar Natak may be moon and fire were later named after great persons like we have ople star named after dhruv and venus after Shukra we have ploto and many sucgh stars.

So kshtariyas are not devine and Rama and his linage was of m mixed type some good and many worse and so could be said for the family of Guru.Baba Abhye Ram and Dheermal and Masands of Ramraya were not in very good terms with Guru.And too remove the high born type of thing is Sikh did Guru used this illiustartions.

Had Prof Gurumukh Singh was as great in Braj Bhasha(dialect of hindi) as Prof Sahib Singh Ji he would have used the very same Vachitar Natak to show Baba Khem Singh Ji the truth.

Das will now answer some other question which followers of Sirdar Sahib arose.

1. Why did not Guru used term Sunnat.
2. Why did not peer Buddhu Shah was meantioned
3. Was God of Guru showen helpless.

Das is awre that Saint Kabeer Ji were never Anti Islam but like present Day Sirdar Sahib himself are aware that like just by saying that I am amrit Dhari and I have licinese to do all wrong so in the same way at the time of St Kabir Sahib just by circumsention people started to claim that they are doing Sunnat.

while sunnat is restarin in the will of God Allah,May be that Sikh schollars himself does not know Islam and is trying to paint it black yet he expet that Guru will use the term Sunnat.

Sant Kabeer Sahib already in Guru Bani gets these words from Akal that cirecumsention is not Sunnat and how female may have it.Lord Jesus also said the same.

Then Guru who is apporving that all the personas enlisted by him bfreore him includin Rasool Akram Salla al Lahe Salle Va Va Sallam were sent by Akal.along side others.BUT

asall are created by Akal as told including Gorakh Nath Ji and then Rasool Sahib and he became the King of Arab and that king made the all male genital devoid.As all Genital have foreskin but after This King all of his subjects were made to make thier genital devoid.And devoid of Foreskin and nver does it is writtan Bad but it is not the Sunnat while ttrue Sunnat Gurmat is preaching and if Guru say that Rasool did Sunnat then why on earth did Guru came on earth.

Answer to this and that question is there and then

in next line Guru writes that it was not thier fault that they did do perfect or thier was a foolproof arrangement there.

Sabh Te Apna Naam Japyo.sat Naam Kaho Na Dhriyao..27..(pg 75)

(Akal) made all(predecessors of Gurus) to say thier own name to be reapeted by(devotees).No one cuold due to this was able to make others see true name.

Das would like to say that by that time there was a situation that already the personal worshipping of Nanak by Hindus(Nanak Panthis) and Muslims(Nanak Shahi) was on.And it was been more being propogted by those Hindu minded to worship Nanak and not Akal and let them be the brokers of Nanak god.

This is still there but Khalsa itself is form of Nanak and does worship Akal and Makwe other worship the same to.So As all others also worshipped Akal but as thier names were used also so people started dead worshipping and worshipping of that which was there sometime or which may had picture and not Akal.Gurubani till this day is used by many so called Sants to preach teh personal worship of First Master.

This does not means that there is fault of First Master,Nath Yogis or Rasool Sahib.It was made by Akal self as Akal does not want all to worship Akal else why did Akal made world to run,only few chosen one know Akal by Akals mercy.

Well God of Guru is not helpless but helpless are those missonaoers who lcak faith and are demoralised by chit of mentailtiy called Hindutva which itslef is demoralsed by evry of thier opponant as being tagged as ISI(Pakistani External intelligence) agent.

Well here peopl in us people use tag of RSS agent or Govt of India agent(Das is sure that Sirdar Sahib are not agent of anyone but his own mentality or idealogy and all balmes on him are false.

Purist are there of Vedas(Arya Samajis),Bible(Yehova Witness formery Bible students) or Holy Kuran(Wahabis) but most are fundmeantilsts and to some extent justifed if we think like them.

Such trent is tolalty anti Gurmat anyway and even in west it was respected at one tiome but now it is descareded as Gurbani ask Akal to Salvage by which ever door/way.
(to Be continued..)

Gurfateh


Next thing is that why was Peer Budhu Shah was not mentioned?

Well why did Peer Ji came to serve Guru?

He made 500 hundred Pathans who were Muslims as mercernicaries serving Guru.

During the War of Bhangani 400 defected to enemy.
When Peer Ji came to know he came with all hsi 750@ followers to help Guru and had his brother and son dead in war.

So Should Guru add that Muslims are treachourus as Pathans defected or Shall he put that peer Ji were incapable to recoganise the honest men and due to mistake of Peer Ji Guru had 400 men serving him defected.

Well this thing does not ends here.

Peer Ji were Sufi Sants and they were not the fighter professeonally so Casualities were vbound to happen.

But in War and Military Doctrine of Priopoganda Los of Self is told minimun and loss to foes is told more then reality we call it pshycological warfare.

And Guru Ji were expert in it and so if he would have mentioned Peer Ji episode then it may not have been coorect on his part to let there be a moral booster.

Coming Back to Avtar of Guru himself.He was Khalsa and we are Khalsa as we purely worship Akal,No Prophet,No Masseah,No Guru ,No Avtar.

And if we see the Bani of Tenth Master say Japu Sahib,He does not use the name Nanak nor may he use his own name least people started to worship him.

Sometime 'says poet' term is used.Gobind,Mahakal,Syam are all name of Akal.

Das will in futre try to explain what actually is in Triya Charitar and weather Mahakal is ShivJi or Not and why Shiji in Hindus are called Mahakal and how is that differant from us.

(To Be continue...)
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Dasham Granth
Well so now Das will try to put some light upon the term Mahakal.
In Akalustat we have a term used which kal(Sabka Kal) and Sarab Kal for Akal.
And so far say for few verse where Akal is refered as killer of Demon Mahishasur(in Hindus it is devi Durga) most poeple say that it is authanitic by Guru.
Regarding male oppression to female but hypocarcy of equality as shown when females were not allowed to perform service at Darbar Sahib Complex we could say that Akal can be Killer of Murr Demaon thense Murari in Guru Granth Sahib Ji but can not be killer of Mahishasur as due to pagan hindu influence our present days anti Dasham Granth Schoolars will think that God is male like Vishnu(in hindus term Murari is used for him) buyt can not be Mahishasur Mardan.
or killer of Mahishasur.
Well writer of Dasham Granth which Das want to say was our Tenth Master did not wanted to breack the devotion to neo converts or potential converts to be more preises but rather wanted to channelise it in a correct direction.
So Guru wanted to say that killer of Sumbha,Turks ,Pathans,Madhu ,Kaitabh,Mahishsur etc. was not any deity but Akal only.At the advance stAGE OF old Sanatan Dharama this was there before the advent of hindusim ,which is naothing more then persdonal worshipping.
Then Das wuold like to spcify the term Chandi,Bhavani and Durga before Mahkan and how Kalka and Chandka are actuially not the she demons as Sirdar Sahib said while hurting the sentiments of Hindus so that they also feel Bad of Panth and hate us and we not succed in converting them in our faith.
Well in Japu Sahib there is verse Ati Dutt Prachand ie super/etreme speed Super/special speed making sound.
Chand has two root words chan and Da or Dda.
Chan specify speed(chan chal is speedly moving) and Dda is for sound when two things crash with each other(eg Kha(deep) Dda(sound in it on crash).
It is quite complex but for non sanskrit user but in Punjabi also Chandd is the term used for a slap on face.This can be confirmed.
So a term Chand or its adjective form Chandi has more to do with Teghan or sword. Bhai Veer Singh Ji did do a good lot of work on it.If he could be wrong then Das can just for say can say that Prof Sahib Singh Ji could wrong and thesne the interpetation done by him on which Sirdar sahib ji are making fun on devotee Sikhs like Rara Sahib,Damdami Taksal,AKJ or Nanaksar are more doubt full.
Does not sword has the same attribute of speed and crash and another name is Khagad Kh(in) G(going) Da(crashin sound).In fact in past old Santan Dharam there was no idol of Devi but sword was Devi but it was hi9ndusim and Sakatism and Three m or Tri Makkar which did the damage.During Ardas another term used is called Bhagwati for it.Bhag means vagina and wati means the possesor and sword is the womb of fighter.and it is in case(Myan).
As Kirpan ie Kipa(Mercy) Pan(hand) of Akal is there so even if sword is tghe symbol of Akal then as a creater then thinking protector as a creator is not bad as without protection creation is none issue.
Durg means the castle it is even said in new testmeant that God is my castle. or Refuge or sheild.And like Ram becomes Rama(in Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji) so Durg can be called as Durga and then term used often comes as Durga Shah(lord).
Well nowhere in hindu mythology Arebic term for lord is used for lady Durga but to shiled of Sikh Durga Shah term is used.
Then for Bhavani it was clerarly said that omni Akal(Time in truth) father of universe from that Akal does glory became famous,Thaht Akal is Bhavani and that Akal has made Creation.(Das was lughing that once someone gave a verse of Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji that one who worships Devi becomes a female in the next birth as an explame proving the above verse contradictory to Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji)It is all the matter of level of eduucation one gets.
Litterlay Bhavan means present or happening and Bhavini is nothibng more then adjective.
Now e come on Kal and Mahakal.
Yes Shiv Ji are termed as Mahakal in hindus and in Ujjain there is a temple called Mahakaleshwar demolished often by turks in past having shivlinga with moushtaches.Story by which Shiva became Mahakal as foollows.Rishi Markande was having life only for say 12 years.his Father another Rishi perhaps told him to worship Shiva to evade the death.
We may see in India a photograth of a black man who is trying to tortutre the young child and a feet on shiv linga.Well first Death came to take child Markande but Shiva killed it ,then god of ?Death came and shiva killed it too to protect the child.Then all angels/demigod prayed for mercy for teh ballcence of earth to be maintained with death.
So Shiva revived the Death and Angel of Death Yamaraj on the condition that Markande will never be touched.
In hindus three pople are considered still alive Markande,Hanuman and perhaps crwaling Ashvathama.
But Gurmat says who so ever is created has to be destroyed.So GurmAT may not agree to this story and Das will give an examples from very so called Contraversial Vachitar Natak and even Triya Charitar which tells that Shiva is from the feet of Akal.Akal has all feets so not a single feet and as Akal has Kar(Hand) , Kripa(mercy)Katkh(vision) so Feet of Akal means that just from lowest of lower power of Akal is bigger then Shiva and a good lots of truth about wothilessness of Linga(Phalus) and worthilesssness of postures which also clears the doubt that writer is not Tri Makkari.

Akal Sahai
Shri Triya Charitar Prabodh
Das would like to say that Das will be happy to tranlate any of the Charittar from 405 whicher any one may ask but one at a time but due too its translaton into English it may look very scholarly and acceptable and not as graphic.
So had they been writtan by the writer in English or such language to which many of ouur people are impressed then it might have beened demed as acceptable but is it OK to say that writer of them had used 'Bad' Language.
Das is happy to write the details.
So Far in India some eople who claimed that they are brahmns due to their Brahmins forefathers they tried to exploti the masses Das will term them pseudo brahmins or in Short pbs.
pbs did not let the so called lower caste have any mony but exploited them from thier labouer via other two castes of Pseudo Kashtryas and Pseudo Viashyas as they were saying themselves to with caste by birth.
The other two caste had money which pb wanted to have.
pbs were having the relims of treatment with themselves.As per there ayurveda mastrabution and nocternal emmission are ailment while ynani,tibb,other hight class sidha/ayurveda and even Alopathy consider them as natural.
Pbs keppt them as an ailment. as a hoax so that more and more young people from higher caste come to them and get treated;. They made talk of sex as tabbo in Indian Culture(Triya Charitar is attacking suppresssing Brahmanical culture).So young people could easy get misguided and were afraid of ailment caused by nocturnal emmmisssion or mastrbution and may come to get reeated by pb vaidhyas.Ths thing appled more on males who controled the finance.
Not only were Peseudo Brahmins were exloiting them in this way but after treatment just to let them test there might they were being taken to Ganikas or Devdasis(sex slaves like the sadhvis of Asutosh Ji Mahraj) in Temples higher castes.
As they have something to do with secret so they did not talk about it or talked in secret oor say resricted language of Sanskrit.This was the system in force to explot the weallthy.
Poor lower caste did indulge in sex only to increase the man power to work so in midle age also Hindu Population still resited the demographic attack by Muslims exponential groowth due to polygamy.
In such circumstances when a defeated creed is busy in sex to forget the defeat and PBs are spreading false rumors about the health and forcing upper strta to adultary vide sex slaves oor lower part of socity is also indulging in mass reprooooduction there was a revlootion dome by the writer who as per Das is Tenth Master.
For the side of Sex or Erotica this multi dimensioanl litrature has many usage as writer himself was expert in many dimensions(Sarv Kala Samrath) and he wanted each of his form(Khalsa) to be like him.
List of usage as follow:-
1. from the art of fulfilment of sexual desire form know onward there was no need to go to Brahmin sorry PB or thier agent Ganikas or Devdasis. And from single partner this can be obtained.
2. Person comiting adultary is not writtan in very poostive light but like a true wariier the cunningnes of of wrongdoer is appriciated as it gives us lesson to safegurad ourselves in future.
3. Even while having a single partner we were told that never to put God behind the partner wife or husband as Goswami Tulsidas JI did at one point of time. as wife is not infailable so male must not put her in front of God.
Janani Pitah Lok Sut Banita Koi Na Kiski Dhraya
Dhan Dara Sampat Sagal Jin Apni Ko Jan In mai kichh Tero nahin..
And so on are instance given in Guru Granth Sahib Ji then as we say that writer is giving term wife here as writer is male but for female reader it must mean to put Akal Before her Husband as Akal is husband of soul.(This is against the hindu idea that husband is God for wife and Pativrata or Sati(Loyal to husband) women is greater then gods).
4.So das is repating that writer wanted to have knowledge of sex and that also to all irrespective of caste so for that only the language used by 'lower castes' was used as writer knew(it is wirittan perhaps in Sau Sakhi that Guru Said that Brahmins who are hating you today will come to your door Khalsa Ji seeking alms one day) that these lower castes who are poor toady after they became king then there may be an attempt by Brahmins to misguide them into art of sex and like father does to his children to there safety from pimps oor quaks so did Guru made Triya Charitar for us to not to fall in trap of PBs(I(n fact most of the people entraped by Maithali Jha Pandit Asotoosh have not read Triya Charitar).
in summery
1. no need to suppress the desire and take the pleasure os sex with partner(wife or husband ) to teh fullest.In Siri Rag Also Guru did write
rsu suienw rsu rupw kwmix rsu prml kI vwsu ] (15-12, isrIrwgu, mÚ 1)
ras su-inaa ras rupaa kaaman ras parmal kee vaas.
The pleasures of gold and silver, the pleasures of women, the pleasure of the fragrance of sandalwood,
So here it must be read as pleasure of women for men and pleasue of men for women as here there is talk of sexual pleasue and Guru Ji did not oppose it like Budha or Mahveera etc.
2. Do not commit adultary and beware of it.
3. Put God in front of sexual partner.
4. This applies to whole gruops of people.
Laslty in this topic Das who has lived a large part of his life with so called 'lower caste' Hindu it is commen in them to use graphical or say rought language when compared to higher caste.
people may say that they are not educated but at that time many followers of Guru were also so far been deprived of thier education and Guru used their language to eduacte them. And say even if they are not educated in say litrature but they are master in vocational science/arts like shoe making,weaversship,blacksmithship ectc. For PBs oor caseists forces this may not be anything but for person like Das or any Sikh such works are equally important and even more usefull in some cases than say litrature.So illitrate sweper may not be uneduacted as he is master in the art or scince of sweeping and cleaning.
We need to rember that at present single x or adult film with errotic oor vulger scens are used to spread aids awareness in India as govt is aware that people who like to see them have more risk of Aids. In the same way sexual oorientation of the people of that time was put in proper channle by Guru to make them aware so that there was not single case of outraging of modest of women by Khalsas at that time.
At present this may not be the case as many of the Sikh soliders in Indian securty forces are not even aware of Triya Charitra.
Other important thing to rember is that there could be other facotrs which were in Triya Charitra as Guru was haing Multi dimension intellect.
like
1. Lessons of politics
2. hidden messages of warfare strategy
3. Propogandawarefare to castist hindu foreces and comunal muslims forces and lableing the miracles/belives of superstitoions(which were anti vedic and anti katebic) as nothing but a coverup over adultary.
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Mahakal ,Akal Makar and Shiva
Well Das would like to say that in past das has come accross many hindus who have been sayiong that ouur Panj Kakars are nothing but an extension of there 'Panch Makar'.This is nonesesnse becasue as per Tantra(sceince to tap system ruuing in sapce) there are Trey Makars ie Mans(meat),Madira(Alchhal) and Maithun(sex).
They are such a dud that they took the work of peoples like S. Bhag Singh Ji Ambala(himself an ex Hindu ?like das) that they have started to say that Tenth Master himself was doing something with Makars(ms). Das is lacking time else das could have given complete antidote to critiques oof Chaupai Sahib given by S. Gurbax Singh Ji but Das will give it someother day.Das can just put thing like to show you all that how iresponsible sirdar Sahib ji wrote that critique
There is a line Maran Kaal Ka Trass Niveriye
Delver from the tragedy of the time of death.
Well there he took death as the time of physical death and not of spritual death whoich caomes by forgetting God.
And can Guru be afraid of such thing the answer is no.
Guru did used term dog(Kukar),Neech(lower) for himself and used term Papi(sinner) etc. Term Dolna or getting aloof from spritual goal and preying for protection from Akal to prevent such state was also asked by Gurus in Guru Granth sahib Ji.
That does not mean that Gurus were like that but Gurus were delvering such verses from Akal which were to be used by sinners oor people who were lower spritually and these verses were to uplift them.
So this Trass of Maran Kal was not with Guru but initials converts who were yet to be Khalsa.
Das can do go word by word Anti dote for Sirdar Sahibs writing but Das is at present more concerned to undo this myth that Mahakal of Dasham Granth is Shiva.
Das would like to tell that at one point of time perhaps young child Markande was destaind to dies but he worshipped Shiva and Shiva killed Death and god of death Yama to save Markande so is he called Mahakal.
There are cults of yogis who may or may not be realted to naths but do consider Shiva as Mahakal and no other separte Mahakal is there.
As per Nath Yogis there creed is also etrnal there first Nath is Bhole Nath(shiva) Next is Bhairo(Kal Bhairav) and so on and so forth.
As per the writing of Gorkh Nath Ji there God is also Nirankar but for unty to it we need to do lot of physcal posturing of Yoga.Shiva and Bhairav etc all worship Nirankar as per them.
Needles to say that like the God of Jews,Christians(Unitarian one),Muslims and Sikhs God of Naths is the same but way is not aproved by Gurmat.
But Naths are not anti idol worshipping at least at present.

Das will quote 'contrversial parts' of Dasham Granth to prove it.
Lets us take shiva
266 Triya chartar says stone traped in vagina(Shiv ling) can not be God.
405 states that from the foot of (A)Kal shiva Ji incarnated.Kal Pai Shiv Jo Avtara.
That (A) Kal created Yogi Shiva.Javan Kaal Jogi Siv Kio.
In Vachitar Natak
we ahve
http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=95
from the said page
Mahadev Devan ie God of shiva
Maehan mahantan ie greater than Shiva
Next page repats
Mahdev Devan
Then next page says that without mother and father
but as per Hindus shiva was born out of brahma who is born out of vishnu.
Then God is ermed Mahakal Kalan ie death to super death ie Akal can kill Shiva who killed Death as per myth.(Here writer has made it clear that this God is not that who is Killler of Death or Yama but killer of Mahakal Shiva).
Similar thing can be seen that in Salok Mahal 9th where at one place it is writtan Rama(Son of Dashrath) has gone but Take refuge of Ram(Akal) it is writtan otherwise.
It is further noted that on page 97 we are tlaking about sound of Damaru(a sort of instrument of Shiva) which in fact is sewed(Sita) with Bridge (Set) Chartan(Crown).The instrument of this God is tied to crwon or what we call the supriamcy of this God and all sounds of emothions continous Haha or Huhu(Good and Bad) feelings Laughetr with the diffferance.
Then begul or Sankh is there at present also unlike that of Shiva which may only come at end of world.AS it is still there like fire of doom.
Thing to rember that tenase here is present.
page 98 is more clear
The rosary of heads glorified his neck, seeing which the god Shiva feels abashed.

next isPage 102.
ਚਮੱਕ ਚੰਦ੍ਰ ਸੀਸਿਯੰ ॥ ਰਹਿਓ ਲਜਾਇ ਈਸਯੰ ॥
चमक चंद्र सीसियं ॥ रहिओ लजाइ ईसयं ॥
Chanmak Chandra Sasiyan,Lakhe Laje Isyan.
The moon is bearning on his head, seeing which the god Shiva feels shy
(this may even mean that so called Shiva who has so called moon on his head is also be ashamed after seeing/thing of Lord)
The ornaments of Nagas bedeck his neck. Which have the power of destruction for the tyrants. 46.
(this may also mean that one who has serpant in neck also has many polluted enmies(while Akal has no realtives in any type(See previous pages of the same).

As it is saying that
at page 103.
His gait is like that of an elephant, intoxicated with wine. His loud thunder appears like the roar of a cub in the forest.53
Here it nowhere writtan that God is taking liquer.
In fact to drive Elephant into Artillary bombarding fortess there is no way wrong to let it have becoame senseless with wine and attack the enemies.
Thou art inebriated, holding the terrible sword in Thy hand. Both the gods and demons sing the eulogy of His victory.55.
Here it is writtan that just before it that God has two Tetth very strong and foe run after seeing that.
Thing to rember that Das alrerady wrote that previously God here was said formeless then how can it have all this.
Well in Adi Guru Granth Sahib Ji Mercyfull Eyes(Krpa Katakh),Charam Kamal(Feet like Lotus),Kar Dharyo(Keeping or enabling Hands) etc are writtan to just show mercy and refuge of God as God's limbs or as Qualities of God as limb.
To eliminate foe here to we have mrecilessness to foe(like Auranaga or Ghuandchand) in the form of Tooth.
to put it in more clear.
Fleaing of foe in battlefield due to fear Guru say is the tooth of Akal.
next line well is like this.
As an intoxicated person listen to know one and do as he/she deem fit so is Akal under the control of no one.
So uncontrolable power(Swrod in Hand) is proved by both evil and good singing glory of God.
As evil of Paharis or Mughal were also worshipping Allah or Allakh Niranajan and that was the same God of Guru but in them it was attacking own creed of Khalsa to make them strong.Guru did see evil also as the manifesation of God and a as gift of God to good as without evil good is worthless.Part 2

Page 104 is mor ethen sufficent to prove that God Akal is not the one of Tantrics,yogisor Brahmcharis but above them and actualy that is the one who killed or neutralised evil which was so far ben attributed to Vishnu or Durga so in fact Akal is real Vishnu or Durga.
As Das wrote before that Guru Ji says that Kal is Akal only and other gods and demon are huuman with god or Bad attribute both in Vachitar Natak and Akalustat(as Manas Ki Jaat...Devta Adev,Jachchh,Gandrap,Turak,Hindu Nayrre Nyare Deshan ke Besh ko Prabav hai ie due to regional varitation we have gods,demon,turks or hindus) while vachitar Natak says that Bad doer is Asur(evil) and good doer is dev or god.And All deitiies at the end of Vachitar Natak are termed as Avtar or incarntaions so they were born so were not Akal or eternal so Kal is not the one.Even godess like Radha(she is eternal mate of Krishna in a world called Golok) and Chandi are termed Female women in Triya Charitar.
This all was there to prove that they were not supernatural to be relied upon as they were human and did defeat evial so as a human he can also defeat the evil be it hight caste hindu paharis or Mughal jeehadis.
What later on Germans like Maxmuller decoded that often mythical charectors were human maybe at any time was told by Guru much earlier.
As Guru followed timelss so they were beyond that backage and we need to recoganise that he was ahead of his time.Thats why perhaps if some one reads so Durga Patt by Guru will never worship Durga as femnale godess and maybe reborn as feamle but will worship Durga ie Fortess ie Akal as Durg is fort and Durga means fortess.And in old Testmeant also God is termed as Forestess in Palsm that nothing but a message for last refuge or unbreakable refuge.
ਕਹੋ ਕੁੰਟ ਕੌਨੈ ਬਿਖੈ ਭਾਜ ਬਾਚੈ ॥ ਸਭੰ ਸੀਸ ਕੇ ਸੰਗ ਸ੍ਰੀ ਕਾਲ ਨਾਚੈ ॥੬੦॥
कहो कुंट कौनै बिखै भाज बाचै ॥ सभं सीस के संग स्री काल नाचै ॥६०॥
Tell me, in which direction you can flee and remain safe? Since the KAL dances over the heads of all.60.
ਕਰੇ ਕੋਟ ਕੋਊ ਧਰੇ ਕੋਟ ਓਟੰ ॥ ਬਚੈਗੋ ਨ ਕਿਉਹੂੰ ਕਰੈ ਕਾਲ ਚੋਟੰ ॥
करे कोट कोऊ धरे कोट ओटं ॥ बचैगो न किउहूं करै काल चोटं ॥
Through one may erect millions of forts and may remain under their protection, even then, in the case of a blow of KAL, he will not be saved in any way.
ਲਿਖੰ ਜੰਤ੍ਰ ਕੇਤੇ ਪੜ੍ਹੰ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕੋਟੰ ॥ ਬਿਨਾ ਸਰਨ ਤਾਂ ਕੀ ਨਹੀ ਔਰ ਓਟੰ ॥੬੧॥
लिखं जंत्र केते पड़्हं मंत्र कोटं ॥ बिना सरन तां की नही और ओटं ॥६१॥
Though one may write many Yantras and recite millions of mantras, even then he cannot be saved. No other shelter can save one without His refuge.61.
ਲਿਖੰ ਜੰਤ੍ਰ ਥਾਕੇ ਪੜ੍ਹੰ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਹਾਰੇ ॥ ਕਰੇ ਕਾਲ ਤੇ ਅੰਤ ਲੈ ਕੈ ਬਿਚਾਰੇ ॥
लिखं जंत्र थाके पड़्हं मंत्र हारे ॥ करे काल ते अंत लै कै बिचारे ॥
The writers of Yantras have grown weary and the reciters of mantras have accepted defeat. But ultimately, they all have been destroyed by KAL.
ਕਿਤਿਓ ਤੰਤ੍ਰ ਸਾਧੇ ਜੁ ਜਨਮੰ ਬਿਤਾਇਓ ॥ ਭਏ ਫੋਕਟੰ ਕਾਜ ਏਕੈ ਨ ਆਇਓ ॥੬੨॥
कितिओ तंत्र साधे जु जनमं बिताइओ ॥ भए फोकटं काज एकै न आइओ ॥६२॥
Many Tantras have been tamed and in such endeavours one hath wasted his birth. All have become useless and none hath proved useful.62.
ਕਿਤੇ ਨਾਸ ਮੂੰਦੇ ਭਏ ਬ੍ਰਹਮਚਾਰੀ ॥ ਕਿਤੇ ਕੰਠ ਕੰਠੀ ਜਟਾ ਸੀਸ ਧਾਰੀ ॥
किते नास मूंदे भए ब्रहमचारी ॥ किते कंठ कंठी जटा सीस धारी ॥
Many have become Brahmacharis and have closed their nostrils (in their process of contemplation). Many have worn Kanthi (necklace) on their necks and have matted hair on their heads.
ਕਿਤੇ ਚੀਰ ਕਾਨੰ ਜੁਗੀਸੰ ਕਹਾਯੰ ॥ ਸਭੈ ਫੋਕਟੰ ਧਰਮ ਕਾਮੰ ਨ ਆਯੰ ॥੬੩॥
किते चीर कानं जुगीसं कहायं ॥ सभै फोकटं धरम कामं न आयं ॥६३॥
Many have got their ears perforated and caused others to call them great Yogis. All such religious observances were useless and none of them became useful.63.
ਮਧੁ ਕੀਟਭੰ ਰਾਛਸੇਸੰ ਬਲੀਅੰ ॥ ਸਮੈ ਆਪਨੀ ਕਾਲ ਤੇਊ ਦਲੀਅੰ ॥
मधु कीटभं राछसेसं बलीअं ॥ समै आपनी काल तेऊ दलीअं ॥
There had been mighty demon-kings like Madhu and Kaitabh, the KAL crushed them on their turn.
ਭਏ ਸੁੰਭ ਨੈਸੁੰਭ ਸ੍ਰੋਣੰਤ ਬੀਜੰ ॥ ਤੇਊ ਕਾਲ ਕੀਨੇ ਪ੍ਰਰੇਜੰ ਪ੍ਰਰੇਜੰ ॥੬੪॥
भए सु्मभ नैसु्मभ स्रोणंत बीजं ॥ तेऊ काल कीने प्ररेजं प्ररेजं ॥६४॥
Then there were Sumbah, Nisumbh and Sranavat Beef. They were also chopped into bits by KAL.64.
ਬਲੀ ਪ੍ਰਿਥੀਅੰ ਮਾਨਧਾਤਾ ਮਹੀਪੰ ॥ ਜਿਨੈ ਰਥ ਚੱਕ੍ਰ ਕੀਏ ਸਾਤ ਦੀਪੰ ॥
बली प्रिथीअं मानधाता महीपं ॥ जिनै रथ चक्र कीए सात दीपं ॥
The mighty king Prithu and the great sovereign like Mandhata who had demarcated seven continents with his chariot-wheel.
ਭੁਜੰ ਭੀਮ ਭਰਥੰ ਜਗੰ ਜੀਤਿ ਡੰਡੰਯਾ ॥ ਤਿਨੈ ਅੰਤ ਕੇ ਅੰਤ ਕੌ ਕਾਲ ਖੰਡੰਯਾ ॥੬੫॥
भुजं भीम भरथं जगं जीति डंडंया ॥ तिनै अंत के अंत कौ काल खंडंया ॥६५॥
The king Bhim and the Bharat, who had conquered and brought the world under their control with the strength of arms. They were all destroyed by KAL, when they were nearing their end.65.
ਜਿਨੈ ਦੀਪ ਦੀਪੰ ਦੁਹਾਈ ਫਿਰਾਈ ॥ ਭੁਜਾ ਦੰਡ ਦੈ ਛੋਣਿ ਛੱਤ੍ਰੰ ਛਿਨਾਈ ॥
जिनै दीप दीपं दुहाई फिराई ॥ भुजा दंड दै छोणि छत्रं छिनाई ॥
He, who hath created the frightening dominance of His Name. He, who had snatched the earth from the Kshatriyas with the strength of staff-like arms.
http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=105
see this link also
See page 108
Kal Hi pai Bhyo Brham Siv Kal Hi Pai Bhyo Jugiya Hai.
At the instance of KAL, Brahma appeared and also at the instance of KAL the Yogi Shiva appeared
this can also be writtan as Akal's only feet became Brahma and that only trook form of Yogis or Shiva.
So that is more than sufficent what Das think to let it be claer that Akal is not the one bvounded by Yogis or Shiva
Then
All the other prevalent object are within KAL(time), only One supreme KAL is ever Timeless and eternal.84.

At other places Sambh Thapna or making Linga(Panch Makri do the same in creamtion ground) is also termed usless.
see the link
http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=111
and few verses
Thou hast recited the name of Brahma and established Shivalingam, even then none could save thee.
Thou hast observed millions of austerities for millions of days, but thou couldst not be recompensed even for the value of a couldst not be recompensed even for the value of a cowrie.

The Mantra recited for fulfillment of worldly desires doth not even bring the least gain and none of such Mantras can`t save from the blow of KAL.97
Here Das will write it agaqin
Kamuk Mantra Kasire Ke Kam Na Kal Ko Ghav Kinhu Na Bhachyo.
THIS IS FOR THOSE WHO SAY THAT IT IS BY MAKKARIS AS THEY DO HAVE KAMUK MANTRAS SOMETHING TO DO WITH SEX AND JUST RECITING THEM DOES NOT DELIVERS FROM DEATH.
Here As in Akal Ustat we have Sabh Ka Kal,Sabhan Ka Karta ie Death of All,Creator oof so as an Attribute we can say that Akal is termed as Kal ie time or Death for enmies / godess or god of foes.
In fact MahKal Kalka,Deb Kalka or Mat Kalka also has a deeper meaning.
ie super death to time(elinator of time),Deb(i) Call Ka or God of time(as only one under whose control times rests whil all the three hindu gos are bind with time) and Mat Kal Ka or Mother of time ie creator of time as that energy is the one who made matter and change in matter makes time.
Yet without uynderstanding it some missioanries tried to enmass publish Guru Granth Sahib Ji without Raag Mala so that let people have impression that Actual Guru Granth Sahib Ji are without it.
In order to nullify Triya Charitar there were attempts to spread rumours that as few people have initiaated the Chaupai Sahib from Akal Ustat during Baptisim so Chaupayee Sahib of Triya Charitar is false.
Lator on it was termed that Baptism is false.Them liewise some respected person said that Damdami Bir was Granth is Granth(book)of Tenth Master.
In desperation due to lack of faith does make many of us feel afraid and we use unfair means.God deliver us from such things.
Das will only give two more exapmple from the same page
Why doth thou indulge in false austerities, because they will not bring in gain of even one cowrie
O fool! Fall at the feet of Lord-God, the Lord is not within the stone-idols.99.
http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=112
all these things are going against what Tri Maakaris were doing.
They do a sort of Mantra(recital of verses) and Yoga(Vachitar Natak has fun making of one who do Parnayamas) so that a serpeant or Kundalini gets set into then via there Swathidhyan Chakra(it is near Genital).
Note Das will some day give name of this gland in medical terms also.
As during climax in intercourse there could be some time of relaxation they tend to find pleasure in that and in order to provide potency to there sexual health they may eat meat and wine.
Such things are often doen in secret places where peo-ple seldom go due to fear like creamtion ground where even the human reamihns are eaten from half burnt pyre.
That sort of thing weahter make them powerfull with supernatural power or not is not the question but weather it has any relevense with Dasham Granth is the moot question.
Well answer is that lower caste people who Guru wanted to make rulers were entrapped by theses Makkaris and were in this occult and such thing made them usless punk unworhty to fend for themselves.
So Guru did use there vocbualry to let them get out of the cluches of Makkaris who too were not muchj bothered about caste but were often lead by Brahmins but having Jajman(devotees) from lowest to lower caste.
So weapn which was so far used to sacrife goat to devi became devi and defeated High caste Hindu and Fantic Muslims.
Usage of meatin food was allowed and so was use of Alchhal in meidcine or in war(as Chemichal only to arise Elphant etc.)
And all fear of unknown wide Dakinis or dead was over come by telling that such things are treival for Wariors.
Sex was also becoming something very small in front of person who sacrifise as it is writttan that Many Apsras or fairies run to get hold of dead in WAr(In Islam concept of Hurries is like that to be given after Qayamat(Doom) and forever).
Here it is after death but if Warrier is religeous he/she get higher status inspite of attempts from Apasara.
ie even after death Sex can act as allurement but Warrier dod not go and Apsara themselves come and keep on trying continously(but nver succed).
Das would like all to read Dasham Granth carefully and try to understand it only after dep look and not relying upon work of any other.
like if someone say in this case that S. Bhag Singh ji said that Chaupaee Sahib Ji are translation of some Hindu scripture then there are verses in Guru Granth Sahib ji similar to that of Holy Kurans mention or look like Vedantic.
But we know that Vedantas have no concept of devotion so ego increase and such people can not make united coharant fightinh force.
So instance or attributes could hvae been taken from past but to use them to sing the glory of Akal as Akal is only worthy for all attribute.
Das at last may ask to put any number from Triya Charitar which is seemed to be vulger and Das can explain them.
As Das is busy with other works so it may take some time but one or two numbers can be given.

Das repaeat that audience of Guru were people from diverse Background not Khartris or Jatts or Punjabis or Biharis or Telis only and thinking this in mind and after broadening of scope we can get good answers.
(Concluded)
 
Sep 4, 2005
266
236
Punjab, India
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

I fail to understand what purpose is solved by Dasam Granth. If Guru Gibind Singh jee had written it to provide sex education to his sikhs along with spritual education (as mentioned by Vijaydeep Singh), He would have included all that stuff in the Guru Granth Sahib. To say that Guru Jee wrote all that rubbish to educate us on sexual matters is nothing but height of mental derangement on our part.
For centuries Brahmins used sexual mythology to subjugate rest of the society and reduced the Hindu philosophy to a low level. Sex had always been used in some form or the other in various Hindu literature to distract the masses from the supreme creator of this universe. The result is that today a common Hindu is not stimulated to devote his senses towards the Almighty, rather his mind is been constantly bombarded by mythology full of sex and he is being amused with stimulation to basic instincts. This has been done by Brahmins since centuries and in the process the original philosophy of Hinduism is lost for ever.
Now, same process is being repeated by the Brahmincal mindset of a part of Sikh derawallas who want to control the illiterate and semi literate population by entertaining them with high grade senseless mythology of dasam granth.

A Sikh's aim is to remain in tuned with the Almighty. This birth is a big chance to meet our Gobind. And that is why guru jee gave us the treasure of Gurubani in the form of Guru Granth Sahib. We have a short life to fulfill the desire of being one with God. Why waste it on unnecessary illogical baseless mythology !!
 
Sep 4, 2005
266
236
Punjab, India
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

(So may be in triya Charitar or avtars or other thing lots of things reagardsing preaching,Deception ,logistic and many messages are decoded.Yes they may not have value for Clerics or Sants who are Sants only but for fighter, for spies ,for ploticians male or female like Chankya style or Shukra or Vidur or shkuni or Alif Laia or Rostan or Bostan or Parable or stories told by Jesus Gospels just imaginory to let others understand or in our Gurus case only selected few understand other hindu or turks who are after luxury of immoral sex or lust or under Shringaar Rasa will only get thing which they like ie pervert mind will sea porn images and forget real message as being deviated.)

Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh
I must humbly submit that the logic being presented here to justify Dasam Granth and immoral behavior and play of sex in it, is too perverse and unacceptable to any person in a right state of mind. The writer is going that far with perverse logic gives rise to possibility of doughtfull intentions.

Sikhs have to be really out of their mind to accept such a writing depicting immoral behavior and display of sex acts as their religious book !!
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

Well Das does appriciate the concserns of Brother Manbir Singh Ji and would request him to get any of the story of 405 Triya Charitar which is encouraging immorality.

Well Das would like to humbley submit that other than one verse which is included in Salok Mahala 9th which is also contraversial there is not a single verse of tenth Master into Adi Guru Darbar.

Well this logic that it(Triya Charitar) would have been included in Adi Guru Darbar for its being writtan by Guru Gobind Singh Ji renders Japu Sahib,Akal Ustat and all of his writing in shadow of doubt as none is included Adi Guru Darbar but in Dasham Granth.

Das was reserching on an issue that if Damdami Bir was made even before Guru's leaving Anandpur Sahib or Not and its result will uncover more fact.

At present Das can say that most of the writings of Tenth master are in Dasham Granth ji Sarbloh Granth Ji seems to more concerned with the conduct of soldier and Politician along side the conduct of saint and any of the vrrse from it quite easy to rise corugiusness inn us.

While Guru Granth Sahib Ji are more to do with Saintly conduct of the householder who may never come into the contact of wrong type of females/males while on mission away from house.

coming on Sexual pleasue.Well perhaps it is writtajn in Akal Ustat and may be in Bani of St Kabir(Das is not sure of latter) ie if the suppressing sex we get salvation then enouch would have been salvaged.

Rather overtly often many Brahcharis still are loose covertly. But Guru correctly state that there is plasure in women as we see in Guru Granth Sahib Ji Ang 15.

It will be hypocracy on our part like the protestant christian who have sismilar double standard.

Having satifying full bodly needs from partner is a sort of safegurad for us from getting carried away from allurements of honey traps by immmoral people.

Das is repaeting that Das has full faith in Guru and does not dooubt Guru while there are some Jathas which doubt even the last part of Guru Granth sahib Ji but does not allow even the question to be raised about there founder even if something absurd is related to him.

Das just want to say that does anywhere in Our Adi Guru Darbar is it writtan that we must not have a wife/husband or we show restrain in realtion with that partner.

Only thing das understood from Guru Granth Sahihb Ji is that always put God before any family relation.Yes in many hindu socity of upper caste talking of sex in Tabbo and and many cults in hindus do say of restarin while within married couple and sex only to give birth to children espeacily the Vaishnav sect.

Yes in Panth Khalsa since the time of Babu Teja Singh Ji of Bhasour there are attempts from high caste vaishavs to dilute Gurmat into ritualistic cult.

Das is sorry to say hard words but without reading often many breathren tend to jump gun.

At Candan in Sachcha Sauda we already have correct interpetaton of Triya Charitar and das got to know it from Damdami Taksal website yet Das would like Respected Manbir to give an instance of any of the Charitar of Triya Charitar and Das will explain what exactly is conveyed here.

Das is repeating that as told before there are many kinds of multi diciplinary education we are able to get from most part of it.

Regarding Pseud Brahmins spreading prevert things then Asutoosh ji Mahraj are still on job but there successfull counter offinsive is being done by BABA HARNAM SINGH KHALSA Of Damdami Taksal or Nihungs or Even Baba Virsa Singh but all are aware of Triya Charitar and consider it as per Gurmat.All others just make sound.

Another thing that more we suppress natuarla thing like sex which is instinctive to us it gets more stretngh in us and we tend to become prevert more and more and such thing of suppressing as yogis have been doing is not allowed in us.

We are only debarred from goiong out of wedlock and anyone who tries to supppress such desire and try to be Brahchari(Calibate) has more chance of getting astray.As inn his mind there is always a fasination for hidden friut.

Know the thing here is that weather we think Gurmat as narrow minded suppresive faith which ritualisticor universal faith which concludes that Akal is in all atom and as Akal Ustat state

Kahon Bed Bani ((God is in ) somewhere as writing of scriptures)
Kahon Kok Ki Kahani(sonewhere in the story of erotica/sexuality)
Kahon Raja Kahon Rani(somewhere King,Somewhere Queen)
Kahon Nar Ke Prakar Ho(Somewhere (you are) type of women).

If Manbir Sahib can prove(as per Gurmat) that God does not live in immoral people even or if evil deeds are not being done God only Das can can say that Das is wrong.
 
Sep 4, 2005
266
236
Punjab, India
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Well, we are here not taking about suppressing sexual desires. No where have we been told to suppress sex within the confines of social boundaries. But certainly, having a loose character is different from having sex within the confines of social behavior.
Reading Kok shastra or Kama Sutra brings no spiritual upliftment. And not going through this type of so called literature does not mean that a person is a bhramchari.

Sikh is supposed to live a Ghrasht Jeewan. He is supposed to have all the sexual pleasures in the confines of his married life. No respectable person can read the sexual literature of Dasam Granth with his family members.

To suggest that Guru Granth Sahib is for household people and Dasam Granth for soldiers and politicians is nothing but ridiculous.

Another important aspect of Gurubani which we need to keep in mind is that - Any bani not mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib cannot be considered as Guru. If we fail to take this fact into account, then there is no end to problems we have to face both at present and also in future.
'Man is a very cunning animal', he finds out ways and means to distort facts according to personal whims. Guru Gobind Singh jee was too far sighted in thinking and of an infinite intellectual understanding. That is why He gave Guruship to Guru Granth Sahib. Guru jee had the farsightedness to foresee the future and to prevent thousands of gurus cropping up among us, thus He gave the Guruship to Guru Granth Sahib. Now, for Sikhs there is no guru other than Guru Granth Sahib. All other bani can have no sanctity in comparison to the Gurubani of Guru Granth Sahib.

The intellectual level of Sikh community is still not that developed to realize the sanctity of the Gurubani. This is because Sikh society had been under the control of Illiterate sants who had been and are still manipulating the religious affairs as per their lower level of intellectual competence.

I feel its just matter of time when Sikhs are going to realize the real value of Guru Granth Sahib and the unworthiness of all other bani.
 

kds1980

SPNer
Apr 3, 2005
4,502
2,743
44
INDIA
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

wjkk
wjkf

vijaydeep ji you himself said in topic of triya charitar that all the bani,s in the dasam granth are not of guru gobind singh ji.some of them are of kavi ram and shyam.can you tell which bani,s are not of guru gobind singh ji
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sep 4, 2005
266
236
Punjab, India
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

I would like to state One simple fact to everyone -

Those who read Gurubani of Guru Granth Sahib jee would always find that there is so much harmony throughout the scripture. A person never finds contradictions. It gives serenity to the soul of the Gursikhs. On the other hand the so called bani in the Dasam Granth creates so much contradictions and disturbance in the though process that it cannot act in the enhancement of spiritual level of Gurusikhs. There is total lack of harmony that is so much distinct in the Gurubani of Guru Granth Sahib.

Dasam Granth can be compared to routine story book with sex thrown in as a stimulant to the readers. Brahmins tried their best to adulterate the sikh thought process in a hope that it would become the main spiritual book of the Sikhs. But by the grace of Almighty, Ram and Shyam kavis could not succeed in their mission against Guru Nanak.

Sikhs are much better educated and the intellectually stronger now as compared to the time of Mahants. And its just matter of time, because the voice of reason can no longer be suppressed by the illiterate Derawallas.
 

Archived_member2

Archived
Jul 18, 2004
766
3
Germany
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Satsriakal to all and Manbir Ji!

All of our Gurus were married. Sex was not a taboo for them.

Why do some persons wish that our Gurus should have written Granth of their choice?


Balbir Singh
 
Sep 4, 2005
266
236
Punjab, India
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Sat Sri Akal



Yes, Sex cannot be a taboo. It is one of the various instincts God has given to living beings. To the most refined living beings 'We Human beings' God gave extreme level of intellectual capability to understand the very being of this nature. Along with so many capabilities we are given the strength to control our senses, and to use them for higher goal.

How can sex be a taboo by which God brings us to this life. And this life is the only way to salvation. By giving us birth (through sex) God gives us a chance to atain Jeewan Mukhti, this is the only chance we have to meet our Gobind, 'Gobind milan ke aeh tere baria'.

Like with all other senses we have to learn to use them judiciously, learn to control them, learn to use them within limits. Kam Krodh Lobh Moh Ahankar, all have to be under the control of Gursikh and not to let them over power you and make you a slave.

Yes, those who are proponents of writings of Dasam Dranth do not find sex and sleaze that they are looking for, in Guru Granth Sahib. They are unable to find the fiction stuff like romance, sex, climax, villain fighting like routine stuff of fiction novels. But this stimulating material is in abundance in the writings of Dasam Granth.

There are different types of people in this world. Their likings and interests are different too. Some like romantic stories and some prefer cowboy stories. Sikhs who have less interest in spiritual aspect of life get more inclined towards the writings of Dasam Granth.


Gurubani of Guru Granth Sahib jee has 'magical' influence. It makes you forget your worries it takes you closer to the Almighty and ultimately helps you to atain Jeewan Mukhti - Mukhti in this jeewan itself.
 

Archived_member2

Archived
Jul 18, 2004
766
3
Germany
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Satsriakal to all and Manbir Ji!
Thanks for your post.

You started writing with "Yes, Sex cannot be a taboo."
I feel that sex cannot be taboo for those whom God has revealed all the secrets. Or, in other words, he may be freed from Maya and its Bhog completely.

You wrote further "Along with so many capabilities we are given the strength to control our senses, and to use them for higher goal."

Since when has the ego of a person capabilities and the strength to control the senses.
Or, has God given this domain to the ego of a person.

In my view, the human generations would have stopped flourishing if the beings could control the senses.

You seem to be a very religious person. Please give a reference from Gurbani that confirms your following statement "Like with all other senses we have to learn to use them judiciously, learn to control them, learn to use them within limits. Kam Krodh Lobh Moh Ahankar, all have to be under the control of Gursikh and not to let them over power you and make you a slave."

Your next statement is "Yes, those who are proponents of writings of Dasam Dranth do not find sex and sleaze that they are looking for, in Guru Granth Sahib. They are unable to find the fiction stuff like romance, sex, climax, villain fighting like routine stuff of fiction novels. But this stimulating material is in abundance in the writings of Dasam Granth."

Please explain what the following Vaak from Guru Arjan Dev Ji is indicating.

CqIh AMimRq Bojnu Kwxw ]
chhateeh amrit bhojan khaanaa.
Thirty-six Amrits are eating food.

syj suKwlI sIqlu pvxw shj kyl rMg krxw jIau ]3]
sayj sukhaalee seetal pavnaa sahj kayl rang karnaa jee-o. ||3|| SGGS Ang 100
In cozy bed with cooling breezes spontaneously enjoy the experiences of pleasure.

There are so many wonderful Vaaks from our Gurus in this context.

Then you wrote "Sikhs who have less interest in spiritual aspect of life get more inclined towards the writings of Dasam Granth."

This may be your personal angle of view. This may be true also. Nobody else is at your place to watch the world from your point.
This does not mean that the rest of the world is not watching Sikhs from their places.

Your last sentence is this "Gurubani of Guru Granth Sahib jee has 'magical' influence. It makes you forget your worries it takes you closer to the Almighty and ultimately helps you to atain Jeewan Mukhti - Mukhti in this jeewan itself."

It is great to read your experiences. May God give you Mukhti and spare you from wasting time criticizing Guru Gobind Singh Ji's writings.

May God's Grace shower upon all HIS Sikhs (true learners). May their conscious mind awakens and they get to know what the Guru has actually explained.

--------------

Here are few words for all those who are curious to understand Guru Gobind Singh Ji' writings.

The first letter of the word Maya is 'M'.

Ego acts too, with the awareness of 'M' (I).

The word Maya is the combination of 'Ma' and 'Ya'.

'Ma' is built with three Gunas of Prakriti. This is the reason why 'Triya' is another word for Maya.

The meaning of 'Triya' is not only a woman as interpreted by many. 'Triya' is the triguni Maya.

'Triya' has unaccountable ways to misguide the king (Jeevaatmaa). 'Triya' enjoys all kinds of Bhog with the king and engages Him in worldly activities with Godly WILL.

Guru Gobind Singh Ji has elaborated more than four hundred characters of 'Triya' in 'Triya-Charitra'.

--------------

I beg for pardon from my Gurus. As all these are to be experienced by every individual when he grows with True Simran. These are not to be discussed with all who have not come to know Simran.

Love.


Balbir Singh
 
Jul 30, 2004
1,744
88
world
Re: Thus Das starts about Dasham Granth

Gurfateh

Well Das is just dealing with few of the issuesd raised by Respected Manbir sahib Ji and kds Ji.

Well when we talk of Contradicition and Harmony bet ween the verse of Guru Granth Sahib Ji themselves and then With its Dasha Granth Sahib ji it is our own misinterpetations of both the scripture which brings contradictions.


DAS IS REPEATING THE REQUEST TO RESPECTED MANBIR SAHIB TO BRING ANY ONE OF THE 405 IN LIGHT AND THEN DAS WILL EXPLANON WHAT IT CONVEYS.

Well fisrt let it be clear that Sikhs never had the living Gurus but since the time of Fisrt master we have Gurbar akal in the form of Sabad Guru(see Sidh gost).

As per Sau Sakhi much more before that such writing weremade which said that Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji were bestowed Guruhood in Nanded it is said that when we have to undergo charan pahul ie Baptism of feet then corner of the sheet covering Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji dipped in water and taken and it is not the feet of living Guru as in hindus.Later on after Khalsa it became baptism of Sabre.

So it is Sabad who is our Guru.And perhaps there were cpiesof Guru Granth sahib ji before Tenth Master which were without the writing of Ninth Guru.

It may lookm ridiculous to a person like say Das who might be having the menatlity of medivial age or modern age to find differance between useage of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Dasham Granth Ji.

Like das has already mentioned above that there are many things whichcame after Guru Granth Sahib Ji so were not incl;uded there.

Guru was beyond the limit of time or any age and infact much more ahead that time and many thing which we use in intellignece at present are included in Triya Charitars.

Well in Japu ji Sahib we have Asankh Papi Pap Kar Jaye and many -ve things told.

Like wise in the Bani of St Kabir Ji we have verse

Marne Se Kya Darpana Jab Hath Sadhora Leen

why to be afraid of death when coconut of sati(lady to be burnt with dead husband) is in hand(like sati).

Here lathough a good lot of example of sati is givne to make ourself like dead without husband God but descrition of -ve is told to explain +ve and no encuoragemtn of Sati is there.

It was intleect of Guru and his braodmindness which lead to survival of Panth in that area surrounded by foes and not the Miracles as often many people from persoanl worshipping Jathas aclaim.Guru Ji could dod that but he used the earthly ways to deliver.

Das will recomend Manbir Sahib Ji to read the wholoe writing by Das above as it is appearing that some points he/she has not comprihanded.

Well with wife there is nothing wrong to use Kok Shastra if needed.

Kama or Lust can not be defeated by supresing or by yoga or by shouting Wahiguru Wahiguru the whole night but self act will increase self ego in us.

Just b y surroundering to the will of God makes us realise that in Bad or lust full also God only act we need not be hating them and will must hekp them but we need to know them.

Triya Charitar also talks of such people and give us deatil of there acts like before going to an area to be one we are proviede the inforamtation of that area objecticely.

Regarding adultary in Triya Charitar it is writtan that meat of adultour person is worhty to be eaten by dogs.

Then if a man does adultary he will get red hot female of iron in well and he will be forced to do the same acts as he did now with her.

In fact this is notjhing but a message about STD or UTI types of ailments.

Coming back to question of kds Ji weather Kavi Ram or Shyam were the writer or Guru was the one.

As in Guru Granth Sahib we have Bani of Bhatts as per with Guru Bani.

So role of Kavi Ram or Shyam was to decode the messages of Guru to his allies around in to the form of errotic or even absurd poems which would be even when leaked into the hand of hindu or muslim enemies would have deviated their attention into lust from the actual message being sent to target.

In fact often Name of Ram or Shyam can be used to put concealment over the identity of actual sended who was Guru.

We need to un derstand that when we talk of the term religeon in Panth it is unique as it influnece all aspect of our life which included sexual life.

Just by describing adultary in negivte term Guru Ji are givng message that good to have pleausre with wife/husband but nothing out of wedlock.

and then always put God before Parnter as Partner can also become dishonest but God will never.
 
📌 For all latest updates, follow the Official Sikh Philosophy Network Whatsapp Channel:
Top