- Jan 31, 2011
- 5,769
- 8,194
- 55
Harry ji, In a previous post you wrote
"1pm An extremely attractive woman comes in selling a laptop, I note she is wearing a low cut top, I spend the entire conversation looking directly at her eyes and behaving like a professional, of course there is a part of me like all men that wishes to have a quick peek, but again, a big red light is flashing in my head with 'wrong' written all over it"
Now, I commend you from stopping yourself from looking down her top, realising it was wrong BUT the THOUGHT still came into your head. Ask youself, why did this thought come into your mind in the first place? where did it originate from? you dont want to be "like all men" and "wish to peek", you are on this site i'm hoping because you want to attain the truth and become your true self? am i right?
Having a thought of Desire (as you did), but then deciding not to act it out, is cleansing on the 'surface' - like removing a fly from a cup of milk, when the real dirt exists 'hidden' at the bottom of the cup.
Now you constantly refer to yourself as a filthy sinner with filthy thoughts, well, I too have lived, and lived hard, and the only filthy thoughts I have, are directed at my wife, so I have to say that your simran regime obviously is not working if you keep getting these thoughts, and clearly does not qualify you to suggest to others that it is a guaranteed method of eradicating lust. In your posts, I also detect a fear, that if simran is not done, the thoughts will come back, or you will not have the mental strength to deal with your problems, I am not sure this is quite the spirit of simran per se, where you can switch it off and on. My definition of simran is to be connected and in a state of Naam. Where every action and thought is in line with Sikhi, through understanding and logic.
Not having the desire filled THOUGHT in the FIRST PLACE is TRUE cleansing within yourself. And SIMRAN is the method prescribed in gurbani for doing this.
Chazji,
We are never going to agree, so it is important we both understand this, otherwise we are going to get bogged down in attempts to convert the other. I admire your love and devotion, I have always said that, I do try and write my posts so it is clear they are my thoughts only, rather than the universal truth, but different things work for different people.
I am a man, the minute I stop acting like a man, I am either dead, or I have attained complete understanding and enlightenment. Now I have to be honest with you, I am a realist, I have to this date, never met a man who had attained understanding to the point that he would not have been aware of a draw on one of his thieves, in fact, I am not sure I wish to be without this draw, its what makes me human, and not superhuman. I am happy and content with the fact that I can be discerning enough to know how to treat the opposite sex, even though I still have age old animal instincts. I understand these instincts, sometimes they are for good, sometimes for bad, it is a case of knowing which is good, and to embrace, and which is bad, and ignore, this is nothing to do with cleansing, more to live in peace, understanding and consonance.
Priority is not the question, its the purity of heart in which the Seva is carried out. Give what you can, help in any way you can with a pure heart. otherwise the Seva is pointless and just feeding one or more of the 5 thieves within you.
If priority is not the question, and you come across two situations at the same time, one a woman being raped, and the other a man with a flat tyre, then you would not use logic and discretion to evaluate which deserved your help the most? I would rather help the woman being raped with an impure heart (impure heart meaning my motives may be for the self, that I am doing something good) than change the tyre with a pure one.............
The DEPTH'NESS of Simran cannot be described to someone who has never tried it
Au contraire, I have tried it, and found it put me in the same state as drugs do. I prefer to be aware and alert, not doped up on meditation.
baahar ka(n)chan baarehaa bheethar bharee bha(n)gaar ||145||
On the outside, he may look like pure gold, but on the inside, he is stuffed with dust. ||145||
It's your thoughts on the inside which gurbani is describing as the dust here.
On the outside you seem professional and give the client a good deal, on the inside you have the thoughts of looking down the clients top.
please contemplate this jewel of gurbani.
Neither I, nor my shop look professional, the shop is full of computers in various states of assembly, I am wearing my normal attire of a dirty t shirt, old shorts, one pink sock, one red sock, and the local kids pop by every morning to play guess the food stain on my t shirt, professional I am not..., I do not think I will ever not have these thoughts, but I understand these thoughts, and I do not act on them. They do not even bother me, if anything, I am pleased that I have educated myself through Bani as to how I should deal with them, I am in control, not the thoughts, thoughts come and go, that is how brains work, your method of cleansing, I warrant, will destroy a lot more than your thoughts
The soul doesn't need LOGIC, its acts on truth, and complete purity (its made of the same thing as God). Until our mind is in complete control of your 5 thieves all logic by the brain will be in one way or the other influenced by the 5 thieves.
This is just rhetoric, what is a soul? how can I possibly relate to this when I have no idea what a soul is? you are also contradicting yourself, are you cleansing yourself of the thieves, or controlling them?
AMimRq nwmu irdY hir jwpY ]1]
a(n)mrith naam ridhai har jaapai ||1||
They meditate on the Ambrosial Name of the Lord within their hearts. ||1||
pwrbRhmu prmysuru iDAweIAY ]
paarabreham paramaesur dhhiaaeeai ||
Meditate on the Supreme Lord God, the Transcendent Lord.
gur pUry qy ieh miq pweIAY ]1] rhwau ]
gur poorae thae eih math paaeeai ||1|| rehaao ||
From the Perfect Guru, this understanding is obtained. ||1||Pause||
ismir mnw pUry gur mMqw ]2]
simar manaa poorae gur ma(n)thaa ||2||
Meditate on Him, O my mind, through the Teachings of the Perfect Guru. ||2||
I have always said english translations are pretty terrible regarding extracting the beauty and logic from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. If you replace meditate with contemplate, then you have my interpretation.,
Always a pleasure debating with you, I hope you do not find me mundahug brusque, and if so, I apologise